Payday
- This topic has 43 replies, 15 voices, and was last updated 17 years, 7 months ago by
Catching The Waves.
-
AuthorPosts
-
March 25, 2009 at 12:26 am #17481
Jmonkee
ParticipantI’m surprised there’s been no discussion of JoCo’s blogpost from today. It’s such an interesting post, in many ways. I think the most surprising thing to me were the relatively small numbers… The song has been out for a week, and only about 1500 downloads, and he’s made less than $200. It makes all the more amazing/impressive that he manages to make a good living, keeping us entertained. Also it’s kind of sobering… if Internet Superstar JoCo makes a couple hundred bucks posting a new song, that shows how tough and competitive the game is.
On the other hand, it shows how a little bit of savvy and a little bit of talent (or a lot of both, in Coulton’s case) can make small numbers pay off big, in the brave new world of the internet.
In any event, it’s all the more reason to go buy a monkey or banana, or something else from the store. After all, when he feeds us music, we need to reward him with lots of poop! Or something like that…..
ETA: Here’s an interesting post about Jonathan’s post….
March 25, 2009 at 2:08 am #63182kerrin
ParticipantI’d always assumed the numbers were bigger. Although, as Jonathan said, most of his income is not from song downloads. I suspect it is from concerts, as we know the mark up on merchandise is insignificant. <Insert link to one of my interview youtube videos here…..not having youtube at work makes things so much harder>
I always feel guilty that I’m not paying him money more often. I was happier when I was paying a dollar a week and getting a song in return….how I miss those days. Even if it wasn’t one I liked (like a mashup….yeah just the mashups really), I didn’t mind, as I knew he deserved more than a dollar for some of the other songs.
I wish there were someway we could convince Jonathan to write a song a month.
March 25, 2009 at 6:59 am #63188
mtgordonParticipantI bought the “full” set of FLACs a while back: everything except The Aftermath (such as it was at the time) and the Ze Frank tracks. I’m waiting for The Aftermath to come out as a CD before I buy the FLACs. In the meantime, I’ve attended several shows and bought a huge pile of merch (lots of t-shirts, kid’s clothing, coffee mug, the works), and I bought a monkey when his son was born, so I don’t really feel bad about paying as I go.
He still seems to be catching up with working his older material into live performances, which may be a factor in his reduced song-writing output. There’s a world of difference between being able to put together a studio recording and being able to perform that same song fairly reliably live with minimal backing. Maybe the prospect of writing more songs is daunting because it just increases the number of songs he’s expected to work into his live shows? Of course, “Blue Sunny Day” premiered live.
March 25, 2009 at 8:30 am #63190kerrin
ParticipantOf course, “Blue Sunny Day” premiered live.
It does make you wonder, how long ago he finished it, since he was clearly well practiced at playing it the first time.
March 25, 2009 at 10:33 am #63199Spiff
ParticipantI don’t know how significant this is to his overall cashflow, but it seems significant given the low numbers he put in his post — revenue he gets from the ad views on my videos is a couple hundred bucks per month, which will only go up as I add more videos. That’s the Internet’s long tail right there — he makes a song, someone (me) turns it into a video, and then the song continues to make revenue in some completely other stream with no more effort from him. Nice.
March 25, 2009 at 11:08 am #63201kerrin
Participantrevenue he gets from the ad views on my videos is a couple hundred bucks per month
Wow, your videos make a fair bit of money….I shouldn’t be surprised really.
You do take a share too I hope.March 25, 2009 at 1:58 pm #63204Covenant
ParticipantIf only someone I knew would do that with MY songs…
Like… say.. my LARP album which is tailor MADE for someone who could do … say… WoW Machinima….
If only….
;’ ))))
March 25, 2009 at 3:00 pm #63207BorbaSpinotti
ParticipantI am really impressed and grateful that JoCo published those figures – I don’t think I have yet seen anybody else who provided hard numbers like those. Yep, it’s certainly food for thought, and like Jmonkee I was quite surprised how low the interest in Blue Sunny Day is. Perhaps it’s just a symptom of the polarising nature of our hype-driven online world; nobody can keep the hype up for that long unless there are serious commercial interests behind them. JoCo seems to have managed to find a place of reasonable sanity where he can keep himself going by his own rules, and that counts for a lot. If we wait it out, I’m sure that some of the Aftermath songs will become standards like his other output.
On a related note, my friend MoShang (he who ended up with “my Laura” in ninth grade) just got a song chosen for inclusion in the Examples/ folder in Ubuntu 9.04. I am looking forward to hearing what impact that has on him – if a tiny percentage of the people who install that version find and listen to his song, and of those a tiny percentage investigate his other music out of interest, that’s a handful of people he wouldn’t otherwise have reached. So far the measure of his financial success in music is that the generated income actually pays for his music habit, and that is a lot more than I can say. As a next step up, paying the rent would be a triumph!
March 25, 2009 at 3:13 pm #63208Spiff
ParticipantCov — I’d be happy to make a video for one of your songs, if one clicks with me. Send me an email (spiffworld@gmail.com) with a link to your stuff, and I’ll give it a listen to see if anything sparks my creative mojo. If you have any that you think are particularly good candidates, be sure to point those out. But if it turns out that I don’t get any good ideas for any of your songs, don’t be disappointed. There are still lots of JoCo songs which are great songs, but which I’ll never make into a video for one reason or another.
Kerrin, I do take a share of the proceeds. It’s not a ton of money, but it’s more than nothing, and it is fun and validating to actually be paid for something you created just for fun. 🙂
March 25, 2009 at 3:28 pm #63211BorbaSpinotti
ParticipantIt does make you wonder, how long ago he finished it, since he was clearly well practiced at playing it the first time.
It also makes me wonder to what degree that live performance was an experimental injection of a tracer token into his fanbase. Has he done that before with an original song? Perhaps the experiment was to see if the official song release generates more interest after the inevitable YouTube videos have already done the rounds a bit.
March 25, 2009 at 5:31 pm #63213CoolJammer00
ParticipantSo I guess JoCo doesn’t have golden submarines and manservant flossers yet.
Anyway, the only thing I have bought JoCo related is Thing A Week. That was at a show, and that was cause I felt guilty for stealing his stuff.
March 26, 2009 at 2:15 am #63223kerrin
ParticipantThat was at a show, and that was cause I felt guilty for stealing his stuff.
Well people that enjoy his music, download it, and never give a penny should feel guilty. If you can afford an internet connection, you can afford to pay something.
March 26, 2009 at 3:40 am #63226
AngelasticParticipantI disagree. You should maybe feel obliged to repay his kindness, but not guilty. I don’t feel guilty when somebody gives me a gift, because I didn’t do anything wrong. But I do feel as though I should give something back.
Even if he (I presume jokingly) writes ‘already stole it?’ on his donate button, you are not stealing his stuff. He gave it to you. Unless you actually did steal his guitar or something during the show. Then you were right to feel guilty.
March 26, 2009 at 7:14 am #63228BorbaSpinotti
ParticipantI tend towards Kerrin’s view here, but it depends on how you interpret the “gift” of the music. JoCo is pretty relaxed about it, but when other content creators explicitly state that they expect payment in return for their work, it is theft when you decide you have the right to reinterpret their wishes. Most of us are used to working for a fixed wage, and we’d certainly question and fight our employers if they unilaterally decide not to pay us – on an emotional level, any content creator has a similar right (within known risk boundaries) to expect remuneration, and to feel hurt when their content is just taken.
March 26, 2009 at 8:49 am #63233
AngelasticParticipantDoes he explicitly state that he expects payment? Sure, for the non-smiley-face tracks which he doesn’t explicitly link to in a blog post saying ‘download it free, or buy it’, if you go to the trouble of working out the URL and downloading it anyway, you should probably feel guilty (though not if a friend gave you the same track, because they have explicit permission to do so, and you didn’t step past any signs saying ‘this is one of the tracks that are slightly harder to get directly from JoCo’s website without paying’.) JoCo has the right to expect remuneration, but he chooses not to expect or demand remuneration from everybody. This causes some people to accept the gift and give nothing in return, and other people to see how nice he is, give a whole lot in return, and share his work with others so that 13.4% of them will also give him money. I’m encouraged to give JoCo’s music to friends so he gets more fans. But if they should then feel guilty for not paying for the music, then I should feel bad about deliberately making my friends feel guilty. And that kind of goes against the spirit of the thing.
Sure, if you take content from some other content creator who otherwise only shares that content under traditional copyright and expects payment for it, you should feel guilty. But if you download a song by clicking a link right underneath a blog post where the artist himself explicitly says ‘download it free’ then you should not feel guilty. You should feel grateful. You may or may not feel grateful enough to give that artist some mon[k]ey.
-
AuthorPosts
- The topic ‘Payday’ is closed to new replies.