DNA

Home › Forums › Everything Else › DNA

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #17126
    jinx
    Participant

    About two years ago, my father died. While I was assembling some family photographs for use in our memorial service, I came across an unrelated bunch of pictures I’d never really connected before, showing (a) my Dad as a boy, (b) myself as a girl at about the same age, and (c) my nephew at roughly the same age — around 7 or 8.

    All three of the photos, taken at intervals of about 30 years, showed kids unconsciously taking exactly the same pose, with the same tilt of the head and downcast chin, with eyes looking up with a kind of reluctant curiosity at the photographer.

    It really made me start thinking about the DNA that linked us all, and wondering: how much am I ME and how much am I just an expression of DNA roughly identical to the people I’m most closely related to?

    I’d love to hear from people who’ve thought about this. I’m not looking for scientific insight into genomes and meiosis & so on — just an answer to the question: “How much of you is YOU and how much do you think is DNA?”

    #37629
    Gle3nn
    Participant

    My son looks just like my brother Brent, same expressions and mannerisms etc. He also looks exactly like my wife’s brother. The pictures of all three look like they could be of the same person. Both my brother and my wife’s brother are very artistic, have similar personality traits positive and negative. My monkeyboy is the same.

    #37631
    Colleenky
    Participant

    My hunch is that more of who we are is DNA than we’d like to admit. I barely knew my dad, but I seem to act and think like what I’m told he was like, despite the fact that he had little to do with my upbringing. He was around for my “formative years,” though, so it’s difficult to say.

    I wish I knew more about endocrinology, because that seems to have a whole lot to do with how we behave, everything from PMS to clinical depression. It’s unsettling to think that how I feel is more closely related to my brain chemistry than to my conscious will.

    #37639
    CoolJammer00
    Participant

    it might also be habits you take from the people around you

    #37641
    JoAnn in VA
    Participant

    You can’t really seperate your mind and body, nor your self from your DNA- it is all “you” after all. I was just reading where they think that humor is a learned (nurture) trait as opposed to certain gene based (nature) traits such as liking certain foods. But that whole nature/nurture debate seems pretty silly at times too-everyone has both effecting them, no one survives without being nurtured and taught by the adults around them.
    Meanwhile, my mom has told me that I act just like my paternal grandmother, who died when I was two. I can’t stand on line in a store without striking up conversations with total strangers all the time. I just love to talk to people, and she was the same it seems.
    Sorry to hear of your loss Jinx- my dad died in 1999, and I still think of him a lot. He had a large, very positive influence on me. He and my mom made the mistake of having Tom Lehrer records where my inquisitive lil mind could play and memorize them while growing up. Made for a lot of fun during holidays, my 9 year old choices for what to sing around the other adults…

    #37708
    Tindomiel
    Participant

    I think there are a lot of traits we don’t think of being passed on socially that are, and a lot of traits that have a genetic component that we might not assume was there. And then there’s chance and non-nurture environmental factors that also work their way in there. It’s hard to say how much of who we are is predestined by genetics specifically because there’s still so much we don’t know. But the question of how much of ‘me’ is really me is quite a bit older than the discovery of chromosomes. 🙂

    As someone who has chronic depression (family history would indicate it has a strong genetic component), I’m forced to conceptualize a “me” living in my brain that exists separate from a disease that affects my brain. And yet, being immersed in the life sciences, and having done some work on the physiological components of mental illnesses, it would be impossible for me to draw a line between the “me” and the physical reality of my brain, the way my neurons are arranged and how they respond to different chemicals. Where does pathology end and personality begin? I don’t know.

    #37710
    mtgordon
    Participant

    I’m not sure whether it’s genetic or environmental (I suspect some combination), but I’ve gone through some wild shifts in brain chemistry over the last year and a half. I’m not the same person I was before. The good news is that I like my current brain chemistry; while my previous state wasn’t exactly pathological, I like my new state better.

    It may very well be that I tend to associate broad shifts in mood and outlook with changes in brain chemistry, whereas others might be less inclined to see chemistry as playing a role in such things. Some of that may just be a function of what I studied in college.

    (bonus points to anyone who can identify what changed in my life a year and a half ago)

    #37711
    JoAnn in VA
    Participant

    Small, cute, demanding, made you want to go buy more life insurance and needs to be changed frequently? :o)

    #37715
    mtgordon
    Participant

    That’s the one. I suspect that my brain chemistry was programmed to shift after he showed up, which makes it both genetic and environmental.

    #37717
    Shruti
    Participant

    It seems that I have all the traits I hate from each of my parents, except where those traits are mutually exclusive, in which case I tend towards my dad’s characteristics.

    I mean, that’s a slight exaggeration, but still.

    I’m also definitely still the same person I’ve always been for as long as I can remember, without a doubt.

    #37719
    mtgordon
    Participant

    I’m also definitely still the same person I’ve always been for as long as I can remember, without a doubt.

    Give it time. 😉

    #37721
    BorbaSpinotti
    Participant

    @Shruti: That is a pretty funny characterisation. I'm sure you'll reassess things later in your life though ;-) (Spoken as one in the Mark Gordon camp. Mine turned 1 on Saturday)

    #37742
    jinx
    Participant

    Well, for those of you who are parents, can you recognize aspects of yourself in your kid(s)? Or is that something that others have to point out to you?

    #37743
    mtgordon
    Participant

    A general sends an adjutant to visit the general’s daughter, who is recovering from giving birth to the general’s first grandchild. When the adjutant returns, the general asks, “Well, how’s the baby?” “He’s just like you,” reports the adjutant. “He’s bald and ruddy-faced, and he spends all his time screaming, but nobody ever listens to him.”

    Everyone says that my son looks just like me. Sometimes I can see it, but most days not, though I’ve sometimes gotten the impression that he resembles my maternal grandfather. For comparison, it’s only in the last five to ten years that I’ve really started to resemble my father as I’ve ever known him. Then again, it’s only ten years ago that I reached the age my father was when I was born, and I’ve never seen many photographs of him as a younger man or as a boy. Isaac looks a fair bit like me at his age, and he also looks a fair bit like his mother at his age, but I almost get the impression that all kids look very similar at that age (I’ve always had trouble distinguishing between photos of me and my cousin as infants), though looking around the daycare, I’m starting to realize how distinct he looks from other kids (objectively, I suppose my cousin and I do look somewhat alike), in which case… yeah, I guess he does look like me, in a juvenile sort of way.

    My wife is the image of her father, but much younger, and with a sex change. It felt distinctly creepy seeing him for the first time: a walking, talking incarnation of the woman I love as a much older man. I’ve since gotten used to it, but I try not to think about it too much.

    As for other aspects of personality, Isaac is quite musical. He loves to dance, and he’s started to sing after a fashion, and he insists that we play music for him, with my guitar playing being preferred over recorded music. In contrast, my wife is totally tone deaf and has never really been a music fan, which is one of the reasons I hang out with this lot. I’ve started getting even more into music since Isaac started showing an interest, since it seems that his music education will be entirely my responsibility, except to the extent that we farm out piano lessons and the like. I never studied piano.

    Isaac is very fond of books, but there’s no real way for us to tell whether that’s genetic or environmental, since he’s being raised by his bibliophile parents in a home that closely resembles a library.

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • The topic ‘DNA’ is closed to new replies.