Blizzcon ’09

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Blizzcon ’09

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 55 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #17543
    Spiff
    Participant

    Blizzard announced the rules for their video contest this year, and they’re pretty restrictive:

    1) Submit an original, unreleased, digital movie… Original is no problem. “Unreleased” is less clear. Released how? What date is the cutoff for it not being released before? If the cutoff is July 7, when the Blizzcon contest officially starts, then I’m screwed since I don’t have a brand new video that’ll fit the rest of the rules.

    2) The Movie shall be three (3) minutes running time or less. Most of my vids are a bit over 3 minutes, more like 3.5 or 4 minutes. I have a couple that I can trim the ending scroll from to bring them under 3 minutes, but again, those ones have been previously “released” to YouTube.

    3) All music featured in the Movie must either be the entrant’s original musical composition and performance, or music from a Blizzard product. I can only hope that they’ll also allow music that is freely available under the Creative Commons license. If not, I’ve got nothing.

    So, let’s say that I can get by on the music question. Then I have to hope that one of my previously released videos (maybe as long as it was released prior to last year’s Blizzcon it’ll be OK) will be acceptable as long as I can trim off the end and get it under three minutes. My only other option is to put a rush job on the video I’m working on now, but that song is 3:49 even without an ending scroll, so that’s out.

    AND, last year there were three categories (comedy, drama, and action) so you could enter three times. This time there are no categories so I guess you just get one shot at entering (although I don’t see anything about them forbidding multiple entries).

    You know the screwed up thing about tight rules like this? I’ve been in contests where some people follow the rules but not everyone, and then it turns out that the contest owners weren’t actually all that strict about picking a winner that’s followed all the rules. For example, I’ll be pretty steamed if someone submits a 3:30 video and wins.

    So, assuming that I just take a previously-posted-to-YouTube video and scrape off the ending scroll, which one do you guys think is better:

    Cruel, Cruel Moon
    or
    Captain’s Wife’s Lament

    The thing I’m mostly bummed about is that for months I’ve been looking forward to submitting Live in some sort of a “love song” category. But it’s too long to be entered this year. 🙁

    #65721
    JoAnn in VA
    Participant

    Captains Wife’s lament- the work you did on Moon is very impressive, but Captains is funnier and has way more jokes- I think it has a better chance of winning for you.

    When in doubt- ask. Write to Blizz, they know you by now and they have had some serious problems in the past with announcing contests and then giving out awards to people who didn’t really follow the rules. It might help them clarify things for all entrants.

    *mutters angrily “a cookie is NOT a gingerbread house or made of scuptural candy”* Holiday “cookie” contest my healer priest butt!

    #65723
    kerrin
    Participant

    This thread just reminds me of my lack of ability to get tickets.

    Do P & S officially use Creative Commons? We know they don’t mind, but Blizzard won’t bother asking if it isn’t immediately obvious.

    I agree Captains’ Wifes’ Lament is the way to go.

    #65724
    Angelastic
    Participant
    #65725
    kerrin
    Participant

    So they do. Not surprised.

    #65726
    Spiff
    Participant

    I just emailed Blizzard with a list of questions. I can only hope that if/when they respond to my questions, they also update the official rules with what they said. It wouldn’t be good for them to clarify the rules on a person-by-person basis, but for people who never bothered to ask to be able to operate under the broader, more permissive set of rules.

    You know who the three-minute time limit really kills is not guys like me, but the people who make those ten-minute epic tales of betrayal and revenge, with lots of soft focus and slow motion and whatever. Those videos, while over-heavy and self-important, are also gorgeous and full of top-of-the-line production value. It’s not a bad thing for me to have those kinds of videos out of the running this time, although I guess there’s nothing stopping them from editing them down to fit into a three-minute video somehow.

    The winner of the Blizzcon video contest at least the last two times (can’t remember if she won the time before that) is Stone Falcon Production’s “Snacky’s Journal” series of videos. They’re really well done and definitely deserve their wins. I’ve met Jun Falkenstein, who’s an actual animation director whose worked at Disney and Dreamworks (so it’s not a fair fight with noobs like me ;), and she’s very nice. But I just checked, and each of her “Snacky’s Journal” videos have been over three minutes long, with the last two being over eight minutes long. I wouldn’t be surprised if she’s been working on a new “Snacky” to be released in time for this year’s Blizzcon, only to have the rug yanked out from under her by the new three-minute rule. That would really, really suck.

    #65731
    Spiff
    Participant

    I just emailed the lady from Stone Falcon Productions (winner of the video contest the last two years in a row), and she wasn’t planning on entering this year anyway, so the restrictive time limit isn’t an issue for her. She’s gotten a job directing animation at Disney and her personal life is full too, so she’s got no time for machinima anymore. That’s good news for her, although it’s too bad for machinima fans. Her stuff was very good.

    #65733
    SpaceParanoids
    Participant

    You know the screwed up thing about tight rules like this? I’ve been in contests where some people follow the rules but not everyone, and then it turns out that the contest owners weren’t actually all that strict about picking a winner that’s followed all the rules. For example, I’ll be pretty steamed if someone submits a 3:30 video and wins.

    But you’re still considering making a submission that breaks at least 3 of the stated contest rules? Are you just hoping you’ll win so you can piss off everyone else this time?

    #65734
    Spiff
    Participant

    But you’re still considering making a submission that breaks at least 3 of the stated contest rules?

    An excellent point. However, since I believe I can slash one of my vids down below three minutes, I’ll only be breaking two of the rules, not all three. 😉

    Besides, that was my point. I certainly don’t want to be the only schmuck who followed the rules if everyone else is going to submit two-year-old, ten-minute-long Journey music videos, amirite? Worst case, I submit something, it breaks the rules, they disallow it, I don’t win. No harm no foul. ‘Cause if I have to follow the rules as stated, I’m already out.

    #65735
    SpaceParanoids
    Participant

    An excellent point. However, since I believe I can slash one of my vids down below three minutes, I’ll only be breaking two of the rules, not all three. 😉

    Nuh uh! You need to reconcile Captain’s Wife’s Lament with rule 4(v) as well, which makes three rules bent and/or broken!

    4. (v) all lyrics … shall not feature explicit or obscene language;

    Ah ah ah!
    Three! Ah ah ah!

    #65736
    JoAnn in VA
    Participant

    Phooey. He is right.

    #65737
    mtgordon
    Participant

    @SpaceParanoids: Please tell me you’ve seen this.

    #65738
    Spiff
    Participant

    4. (v) all lyrics … shall not feature explicit or obscene language;

    Is there a single instance of explicit or obscene language in the song? It’s about pirates, as my video clearly shows. What did you think it was about? 😉

    #65739
    mtgordon
    Participant

    It’s possible that their point was not so much to prohibit innuendo or double entendre but to exclude the much more overt bitches-and-hoes language of some music. JoCo’s cover of “Baby Got Back” (which traditionally has one word omitted) might not be considered inappropriate. “First of May” seems right out, though. YouTube is cool with your CWL video, yes?

    #65740
    Spiff
    Participant

    YouTube is cool with your CWL video, yes?

    YouTube loves my CWL video! 250,000 views and counting, baby. Woo!

    … oh, you probably meant is YouTube the company cool with the vid? I’ve never received any feedback from anyone indicating that the inuendo in the song is unappreciated, so I think I’ll be fine. Besides, if Blizzard doesn’t dig it, they’ll just drop me from the contest, right? No biggie.

    EDIT — I just re-watched “Captain’s Wife’s Lament” to make sure that there really isn’t any swearing in it. There’s not, but boy, that video, which is hysterical in the right context, could be pretty cringe-inducing in the wrong context. Do I really think Blizzard is going to play that video in front of 15,000 people and on DirecTV if it wins? I had pretty much decided that CWL was the way to go, but now I’m second-guessing myself. Hopefully they’ll allow multiple entries per person so I can submit both this one and CCM and let them decide which is better.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 55 total)
  • The topic ‘Blizzcon ’09’ is closed to new replies.