Reply To: Payday
Does he explicitly state that he expects payment? Sure, for the non-smiley-face tracks which he doesn’t explicitly link to in a blog post saying ‘download it free, or buy it’, if you go to the trouble of working out the URL and downloading it anyway, you should probably feel guilty (though not if a friend gave you the same track, because they have explicit permission to do so, and you didn’t step past any signs saying ‘this is one of the tracks that are slightly harder to get directly from JoCo’s website without paying’.) JoCo has the right to expect remuneration, but he chooses not to expect or demand remuneration from everybody. This causes some people to accept the gift and give nothing in return, and other people to see how nice he is, give a whole lot in return, and share his work with others so that 13.4% of them will also give him money. I’m encouraged to give JoCo’s music to friends so he gets more fans. But if they should then feel guilty for not paying for the music, then I should feel bad about deliberately making my friends feel guilty. And that kind of goes against the spirit of the thing.
Sure, if you take content from some other content creator who otherwise only shares that content under traditional copyright and expects payment for it, you should feel guilty. But if you download a song by clicking a link right underneath a blog post where the artist himself explicitly says ‘download it free’ then you should not feel guilty. You should feel grateful. You may or may not feel grateful enough to give that artist some mon[k]ey.