Reply To: JCCC4: Post Mortem (Feedback Thread)
Home › Forums › JoCo Cruise › JCCC4: Post Mortem (Feedback Thread) › Reply To: JCCC4: Post Mortem (Feedback Thread)
[P] I’ll only comment on this one last time, because we’re approaching tail-chasing territory here…
Everyone who takes part in the Pledge is (with the exception of a few passengers’ children) a grown-up, with the capacity to decide how seriously they choose to interpret and abide by its “rules.” If a person chooses to not use Twit-arr and Cruise Monkey (whether taking part in the pledge or not), and subsequently misses out on some details or schedule changes, then those are the consequences of that person’s choice. (I’m sur that many, like the folks @Icemage encountered, figured they’d just ask a non-Temperance person for updates.)
And unless presented with evidence to the contrary, I find it difficult to believe that reasonable people are being cajoled or coerced into joining the brigade, or into strictly following its rules to the detriment of their cruise experience, out of fear of…what? Breaking a set of arbitrary and unenforceable “rules” with no punishment for breaking them nor reward (beyond personal satisfaction) for following them? That David Rees might get mad at them?
I genuinely don’t mean to be glib, nor dismissive, I swear; but I feel like this degree of concern over the details of the Temperance Brigade is rather like worrying over how much fealty one owes to the Monarch of the Seas. Each is an equally arbitrary, rather silly element of the experience; and people can and do choose to make as much or as little of each as they wish.
FWIW, we haven’t received a single note of survey feedback in the first three years that someone felt forced to take the pledge, nor that they took the pledge and then were upset for missing subsequent communications. If it were a genuine problem for people, I’d think we would have heard something by now beyond conjecture that it *might* be an issue for some.
Okay, enough words.
P.