Reply To: JoCo Cruise Crazy 4: The Basics

Home › Forums › JoCo Cruise › JoCo Cruise Crazy 4: The Basics › Reply To: JoCo Cruise Crazy 4: The Basics

#95498
autojim
Participant
Edit: This is, as @Grimoire points out below, well beyond “The Basics”. Info-dump follows:

MOST ships (of all types) don’t have what most would call a truly redundant backup propulsion system. Nearly all cruise ships working these days are engine-electric, however, with the engines (diesel or gas turbines) running generators and the screws driven by electric motors. There are typically multiple engines generating power — and in theory, if one or two go down, the remainders are sufficient to provide some propulsion and operate hotel loads (which can also be run with other engine/generator sets dedicated to hotel loads). There are still a few older ships running steam turbines, though I’m not aware of any serving the North American passenger cruise market, and there are a number of cargo ships running direct diesel propulsion. Military vessels are variable depending on size/type, including direct diesel, gas turbine direct, diesel-electric, and nuclear-generated-steam turbine.

The new regs that have gone in for new builds effective 2010 have basically driven multiple engine rooms (for fire stop) and redundant control systems, but there are several “choke points” where the two redundant control/power distribution systems will necessarily have to run together. Ships are not going to have backup Azipods hanging off the hull and out in the flowpath just in case of one dropping out. For starters, the increased hydrodynamic drag (non-trivial, even with a feathered screw, a capability most podded propulsion systems don’t have) will increase fuel consumption, plus a system sitting out there in the salt water unused will deteriorate even faster than one that’s in use. Yes, you can set up an operation/maintenance schedule to keep both systems active and exercised, but you’re still having to deal with whichever one is inactive sitting out there and causing drag.

It’s equivalent to carrying a complete spare engine/fuel system/transmission/driveline around in your car. It’s not used — it’s just a backup, after all — but you’re toting around an extra 800-1000 lbs (and either having to increase the size of the car by 30% or so or losing most of your internal passenger/cargo room) just in case the primary system fails.

If you lose use of/damage a pod, as the most recent Carnival ship had happen, result is reduced speed. You can’t fix that at sea: they’re hung under the hull and you can’t open them without dry-docking the ship first (seawater and electric motor innards do not get along well). Yes, it’s theoretically possible: you’d need spare parts, a specialized service vessel, technical divers, figure out a way to attach the rigging to remove the screw, the bearing gland, etc. and not have them wind up on the bottom of the ocean. But it’s a really bad idea (see: salt water and electric motor innards). Likewise, having a service vessel come out and remove the whole pod & replace it at sea is *possible* but would take longer than towing it to a drydock somewhere.

This isn’t something where they can run down to the corner “Boat Zone” and get service parts. Yes, they exist in some quantity somewhere in the world, but they’re very big, very heavy, and take a long time to move around because of that. A C5 or the (lone) Antonov 225 *might* have enough weight capacity to carry an Azipod, though you’d have to remove the screw in order to fit it into the fuselage. Otherwise, you’re looking at ocean transport, which takes much more time.

In my line of work, we deal with subsea and marine equipment all the time, and EVERYTHING takes longer than you might expect. Being in a hurry typically results in more damage than you started with. Big, heavy stuff is difficult to move safely (no damage to humans, the stuff itself, or the stuff around it), and simply takes time. When I have large stuff that requires machine lift (we have a 35lb max for one-man lift, 70lb for two-man lift, beyond that, machine lift), I plan on assembly, etc. taking twice as long as a smaller equivalent. And I have to design in lift points, etc.