Reply To: Christmas Album

Home › Forums › JoCo Music › Christmas Album › Reply To: Christmas Album

#90155
totoro
Participant

At a risk of being controversial, is it just me or does anyone else think the collaboration with John Roderick is going in the wrong direction for Jonathan Coulton? Is it a permanent fixture between them both?

I have to admit, there isn’t one song on the Christmas album that I like – I’ve listened to it a number of times and none of them have yet to grow on me, which worries me a little. I’m a big, big fan of JoCo, I’ve been to his shows, got the merch, got all the albums and the ‘traditional’ albums are never off my iPhone, but I’m worried that Roderick has changed him! Changed him for the worse?

I feel the Christmas album is more like John Roderick’s album, ‘featuring’ Jonathan Coulton, and cashing in on the already expanding Coulton fan base. But it doesn’t feel catchy, witty or clever like JoCo’s normal way of writing.

Maybe it’s just a blip. Maybe I’m not being open minded enough, but I’m hoping Coulton goes back to his solo career for his next album. Or maybe I’m afraid of change…!