Reply To: Song Premiere – Nemeses

Home › Forums › JoCo Music › Song Premiere – Nemeses › Reply To: Song Premiere – Nemeses

#76185
chicazul
Participant

@villicious: I respond very strongly to the timbre of voices, so I understand those who are dissatisfied. I love Jonathan’s voice, and I am far less interested in his songs that feature another vocalist. I think the frequency of complaints also stems from the fact that this is the first album track to be released. Most people would naturally assume a new Jonathan Coulton song would have Jonathan Coulton singing, especially if they haven’t been following the live versions. I love Roderick’s voice too, but had I not been expecting it (and not heard the live versions a million times) I probably would have been a little disappointed.

@MJPM: I am more attached to the way Jonathan sings each of the three songs you mention as potential collaborations than I was to Nemeses, so I will be disappointed if someone else sings them on the album. To each their own! (:
Artificial Heart (the song) actually has my favourite articulation of all, which I deeply hope is preserved in the album version. I’m perhaps strange about these things–I have a favourite moment in the vocals of the cruise performance of The Commander Thinks Aloud. Vocals are a big part of what I listen to in music, which is why instrumentals almost universally put me to sleep.