Reply To: A Newbie Guide to Cruising AND getting there & back again
Home › Forums › JoCo Cruise › A Newbie Guide to Cruising AND getting there & back again › Reply To: A Newbie Guide to Cruising AND getting there & back again
@harpo787. There’s a reason I call HAL “God’s Floating Waiting Room”… (And I know they sign your paycheck, so don’t take this as ragging on the line or its people, please).
Realistically, *most* (Carnival and NCL are exceptions) cruise lines will see their demographics skew older on longer-than-7-day cruises, but HAL regularly runs the oldest. I am very fond of Celebrity (and yes, I know they’re not even corporate cousins of you, being part of RCCL) because they attract a “professional” clientele, yet not one that’s worried about breaking a hip.
I did do one RCCL 11-day early on in my cruising history where one of the midship elevator lobbies looked like a walker parking lot. The young assistant cruise director (who really made that voyage work) told us it was the length of the trip that skewed the age of the passengers. It really makes sense: most working-age folks can’t get more than a week off at a time, so a 7-day is about their limit.
But then I did a 10 day on Maasdam out of Newport, Virginia. Oh. My. FSM. One of our 70-something-but-still-spry cruise “parents” (Long story short: met them on one cruise, went on 7 others with them because they were so much fun) remarked “Look at all these OLD PEOPLE. I feel like a teeny-bopper!” We, in the general neighborhood of 40, were among the youngest onboard who weren’t children or grandchildren of other passengers. I was wondering how many people I’d have to assist to the muster station in the event of an emergency given how many of our cabin neighbors could not negotiate even one flight of stairs.
To be honest, HAL is not the first line I’d choose for a crowd like JCCC. Obviously, it works for The Management, and after the first one, and the booking rush for JCCC2, there’s obviously some synergy going on. But… I could see JCCC working just as well, if not better, on Celebrity or Princess or RCCL. For me, it’s the group that I’m going to be part of that is the attraction to this cruise, not the vessel or the line. Put JCCC on a Solstice-class or Millennium-class Celebrity ship and I’d have my cabin for JCCC3 reserved already: the trifecta of line, ship, and people will be met, if not exceeded.
What it boils down to is the personality of the cruise line. At the pointy end of the North American mass-market, Carnival is a floating frat party, the only thing missing is the naked bungee jumping from the top of the funnel. RCCL is increasingly, with its bigger and bigger ships, becoming the “something for everyone” catch-all, but at the same time, is probably going *too big* with its last 3 ship classes (Voyager, Freedom, and Oasis), as the lines to get on/off the ship, for food, etc. get longer and longer. NCL is for the folks who don’t care for structure at all and don’t mind REALLY SMALL CABINS. Moving upscale, you have the Italianate Costa and MSC, the light-premium Princess (which is maybe a half-step up from RCCL, IMO), the quieter-but-not-stuffy of Celebrity, the stately maturity of HAL. Then you get further upscale to the Grande Dame of Cunard, with its traditions and distinction between “cruising” and “traveling by ocean liner”, and the severely understated, don’t-tell-the-riff-raff-about-us of Seabourn and SilverSea.
Where you see the personality is in the type of entertainment acts booked, in some respects the menu and some of the other services offered onboard, as well as the decor and general “tone” of the vessel. On the RCCL and Celebrity vessels I’ve cruised, the entertainment was targeted toward the 35-50 age bracket and it was generally free of cheesiness (exception: EVERY SINGLE CRUISE I’ve been on has featured some sort of “Big Broadway-style show” that includes someone singing “My Heart Will Go On” from the movie “Titanic”. This is like showing the pilot episode of “Lost” as the in-flight movie on a trans-ocean flight). On Maasdam, we actually skipped out on most of the entertainment early as it was very “Catskills-esque” (Hand to FSM, there was a stand-up comic named “Shecky”) and geared toward the 70+ age group. On JCCC, of course, we’re packing our own entertainment, and this becomes a total non-issue.
To give you an idea here of price differential between the different areas of the cruise market, if I get the SS-category mini-suite I’m aiming for for JCCC2, it’s roughly equivalent $$ to a Concierge Class veranda cabin on Celebrity, a suite on RCCL, a standard suite on Carnival…
…or 2/3rds of a Britannia-(lower)class inside cabin on Cunard’s QM2.
I will add that the staff I met on Maasdam and every HAL employee I’ve ever interacted with were consummate professionals and made our trip thoroughly enjoyable, so in that respect, I’m not in the slightest bit worried — and in fact, I’m looking forward to a week of pampering.