Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
I see the reference in the Declaration as an inversion of the then-conventional European doctrine of Divine Right, in which the Church, on behalf of God, crowns the King, who thereby has a mandate from God to tell the people what to do. Under Jefferson’s model, God gave authority to the people, and the people give limited authority to the government by proxy. In a way, under the American model, the people play the role that the Church played in Europe as the divinely ordained conduits of authority. The important part, though, is that the state is answerable to the people, with none of this “L’Etat c’est moi” bullshit. As a direct response to Divine Right, the Declaration is using religious rhetoric to counter a religious argument against democracy.
The modified pledge doesn’t really serve that purpose. The pledge served its purpose without religious rhetoric for decades before it was changed. The introduction of religious language in this context doesn’t emphasize the rights of the people; indeed, by pledging allegiance to one nation under God, and thereby placing the authority of the populace below that of nation, which in turn is below that of God, one might argue that it’s reasserting the authority of religious authorities over the government, which is in fact the opposite of the intent of the Declaration. It’s totally backwards.
Really, I think the main argument in favor of inserting and maintaining “under God” is that the earlier pledge was seen as insufficiently liturgical for some people’s tastes. They wanted something more similar to the prayer to which they were accustomed. I’m fine with people praying, but let’s not establish a national liturgy, especially one that turns the principles of the founders topsy-turvy. I’m happier with the original intent: you have your liturgy, and I have mine, and as to the specifics, we agree to disagree. We should keep the government out of the theology business.