Reply To: 10/08/09 The Ark, Ann Arbor, MI Show
Home › Forums › JoCo Gigs › 10/08/09 The Ark, Ann Arbor, MI Show › Reply To: 10/08/09 The Ark, Ann Arbor, MI Show
I have the Pontiac show in .WAV at 24/96, but people don’t necessarily don’t want to download or store such large files. Also, because it was taped in the audience, there’s a big dynamic range issue (applause by the people near me blows out the levels to their max, and the performance is much quieter by comparison). So I ran it through the mastering plug-in Ozone with EQ to take down some very low-frequency thumps and foosteps, a multi-band limiter and some widening, which opens up the stereo field a little bit, and they are then downsampled and reduced in word length to CD quality.
Most people’s players will do this anyway — very few listeners have devices that will play audio files at 24 bits. If you’re listening on a PC or Mac, the audio subsystem is taking it down to 16-bit, 44.1 KHz anyway, and the algorithm it uses on the fly is probably not as good as the dithering that Logic can do when it exports.
You’d only hear it at 24 bits if you were listening through a higher-end soundcard like my Apogee Ensemble. And if you’re listening on earbuds or in your car, you _really_ want compression/limiting, or the banter will be completely inaudible, as will all the quiet sections in the music, and only the applause will be loud. I know if you’re a purist then you probably don’t listen to music in your car or on a bus, but a lot of people do. I do both; when I’m listening at work, it’s a very quiet environment and I have some higher-end headphones, but I also like to hear music while I’m driving.
I can hear the loss of quality in MP3 encoding below about 320K, but at or above that point it gets to be a fairly subtle difference, especially on the playback systems most people are listening on.
If anyone wanted the files in 24/96 as recorded, I’d be happy to provide them, either raw or with my processing, but that’s several gigs of data. I’d have to make a torrent rather than just put it up on my web host, and the number of people who actually wanted to listen to it in 24/96 FLAC would be pretty small, I’d imagine.