Reply To: 10/08/09 The Ark, Ann Arbor, MI Show

Home › Forums › JoCo Gigs › 10/08/09 The Ark, Ann Arbor, MI Show › Reply To: 10/08/09 The Ark, Ann Arbor, MI Show

#67156
paulrpotts
Participant

Jmonkee: I am not a lawyer (thank God), but I _think_ the answer is yes, you really can get in trouble posting someone's copyrighted material. I don't think it is likely, and there is some hair-splitting distinction to be made between using an artist's _recording_ and using an artist's _song_. TMBG (or, maybe their label) owns copyright on those songs, both the recordings and the lyrics/music.

JoCo and P&S are allowed to play covers because the _venue_ pays some blanket licensing fee to a right's organization. It doesn't mean anyone else (including YouTube) can legally distribute covers, even for free, although I think the Johns are unlikely to care. Notice that in the case of "Still Alive," to release his DVD, JoCo had to get legal permission from Valve to, basically, release a live cover of his own song, which was work for hire and so the rights are owned by Valve. It's all so complicated!

This mess is why I took the covers out of my recordings of the Pontiac show. I didn't want to have to deal with a takedown letter or damage claim.

There's also something I've never been fully clear on — I know JoCo and P&S release most of their recordings under their CC license, but I'm not fully clear if that same license applies to the lyrics and melody. I'm assuming so since no one told us otherwise when we were recording the Skullcrusher Mountain cover. But then I'm also not clear on whether you can even copyright a chord progression or a melody per se independent of the lyrics or a particular _score_, and exactly how you'd determine if someone playing your chords or melody, independent of the lyrics, was infringing or not.