I think wird does make more sense than werden, because “alles” is singular. It should be “Dann alles okay sein wird.” I think it works if you use a similar rhythm to the equivalent line later in the song (Die M
Sign Up for the Jonathan Coulton Mailing List!
We'll send you four free tracks to start,
we'll never give your address to others,
and we'll make sure you know about the latest
news and upcoming concerts.