Reply To: Seeking criticism on an acoustic song of mine

Home › Forums › JoCo Projects › Seeking criticism on an acoustic song of mine › Reply To: Seeking criticism on an acoustic song of mine

#66205
paulrpotts
Participant

Finally listening to this… some comments:

The guitar parts sound great — very professional, there’s a lot of bass and it’s a nice, rounded woody tone — I’m guessing not a Martin, but a little boomier, maybe a Yamaha? It sounds like a soundhole-mounted mic, am I right? There’s a bit of buzzing, but I kind of like that in a recording of an acoustic guitar.

My only suggestion there would be that it sounds a little over-compressed, and there are some little bits of pick noise on the pickguard here and there. You might consider working on making your pick attack and strum a little more gentle. For a recording you don’t need to generate as much volume, especially given that you have such a clean recording setup.

Regarding the overall mix: I think the guitar and vocals are competing a bit on the soundstage; you might consider widening the guitars left and right to leave some space. Also, some of the guitar fundamentals are very much the same notes you are singing, which muddies it a bit, so you might want to open up a few dB by EQ’ing the midrange of the guitar a bit. I have to say, though, I’m not an expert at that yet!

The singing seems perfectly decent, better than I can do. I guess the only thing I can think of is that it lacks a certain hook, and the lyrics just aren’t stellar or memorable.

It reminds me a lot of Alanis Morisette’s song Everything, but that song’s lyrics are a lot more memorable.

Overall it sounds entirely credible, if not sparkling, something I’d expect to hear on professionally produced indie folk album.