Reply To: Seeking criticism on an acoustic song of mine
Home › Forums › JoCo Projects › Seeking criticism on an acoustic song of mine › Reply To: Seeking criticism on an acoustic song of mine
I’d reprimand you, but the song is pretty darn decent, so I guess I’ll just encourage you to post more of them (in the Everything Else-category, though)
As far as criticism goes, I thought your voice had a tendency to vanish a bit in the guitar, giving a sort of muddy aural image in my ears. You might want to amplify it a bit, or otherwise distinguish it clearer from the instrument.
I could break out some literary criticism on the lyrics, too, but I dunno if that’s what you were asking for… ?
Nice and happy, sort of bouncy tune – goes well with the theme.
Your vocals are a bit shaky at times, I thought. Do you use your diaphragm when you sing?
Also there’s a part near the end where backup vocals kick in “felt the same waaa-aaa – *pause* – aaaayy” – that didn’t sound too great to me. Like you’d tried to sing a note that was too long, so you had to stop and breathe. Seemed like a miscalculated mistake, and not so much a feature of the song.
Those are my opinions, for what they’re worth.
On a personal note, I think it’d be cool if you posted tabs – it sounds like something I might take a swing at playing for myself.