Reply To: What I learned from Jonathan Coulton about songwriting … and monkeys

Home › Forums › JoCo Music › What I learned from Jonathan Coulton about songwriting … and monkeys › Reply To: What I learned from Jonathan Coulton about songwriting … and monkeys

#65824
mtgordon
Participant

I think it’s considered a bad habit that one should avoid establishing, since some things (barre chords come especially to mind) are really hard when the thumb is being used to hold down strings. For the record, I don’t assign much weight to that argument. I don’t know any fingerings involving the thumb, in addition to which I have a certain chicken/egg problem: I have no calluses on my thumb, which means I don’t play with my thumb, which means that I have no calluses on my thumb…

Maybe it’s the fact that playing with the thumb works best when you have exceptionally large hands, and many teachers tend to discourage the use of techniques they can’t demonstrate themselves. Sour grapes?