Reply To: Song Fu #4

Home › Forums › Music Industry 2.0 › Song Fu #4 › Reply To: Song Fu #4

#65642
Edric
Participant

Okay — here’s something a little different…

We’ve been reading a lot of comments about what everybody thinks about everybody else’s songs. I know there are a lot of Song Fu-ers in the JoCo forums. Anybody else care to turn the spotlight on themselves?

“Acceptance” is the seventh song I’ve written for Masters of Song Fu. I was thinking about what I think about each of them, and how I think they compare with each other. It’s an interesting line of thought, because so many of my songs (I think!) are so different from each other. (And yet — I know that I definitely do have a distinct “sound,” if not a distinct “style.”) So I spent some time thinking about what I’ve submitted to Song Fu, and I’ve come to the realization that I need to do a couple of _different_ categories if I want to rank them…

If I were to rank my songs based on which were my “favorites,” the list would look like this . . .

1) All For This Moment
2) It All Makes Sense At The End
3) Extreme Mad-Libs (Song Fu Edition)
4) (Happiness)
5) Blue Moon
6) Acceptance
7) Whispered In Your Ear

But if I were to rank them based on which ones I’m the most _proud_ of, or the ones I think are the best _crafted_, the list would look like this . . .

1) Blue Moon
2) It All Makes Sense At The End
3) All For This Moment
4) Extreme Mad-Libs (Song Fu Edition)
5) (Happiness)
6) Acceptance
7) Whispered In Your Ear

“Blue Moon” isn’t my “favorite” of the bunch, but it is the one I worked the hardest on, and it’s the one with the most going on “behind the scenes.” (You can read about the “science behind the song” by clicking on the “Blue Moon” button on my web page.) It also has one of the strictest rhyme schemes, and took a lot of time to write because it has four distinct sections, with very little that repeats throughout the song. I’m really proud of what I turned out with “Blue Moon,” and none of my other Song Fu songs have come close to what I achieved with that one.

“All For This Moment,” on the other hand, is just gorgeous. And subtle. And lush and romantical. (And, ironically, written the weekend before the Monday of my divorce hearing.) It wasn’t as challenging to write; it doesn’t rhyme at all; it’s half as long as “Blue Moon” (but _twice_ as long as “Acceptance”!) — but it’s my favorite to listen to.

(“Whispered” was just weird. I mean, I like it — and it does an excellent job of giving voice to Daniel Quinn’s Mother Culture. But still — it’s weird…)

“It All Makes Sense At The End” is just wickedly good fun, in my opinion — and it’s also the only song with a title that’s also part of the lyric! “Extreme Mad-Libs” was a conscious attempt on my part to write something that had a “Jason Robert Brown” sensibility to it. “(Happiness)” is another song that I love to listen to — but it’s boring as hell to play on the piano, and impossible to sing alone. (It’s also another song that, while being well-structured, hasn’t any rhyme scheme whatsoever.)

So — that’s my two cents. I’d be interested in hearing what other Song Fu-ers think about their own contributions to this mad little adventure in which we find ourselves. (Would any of them be equally interested in sharing?)

🙂