Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
Whoa, whoa, whoa, I think it’s VERY strong to say that people who are “superficially religious” – which is also a fairly condemning label to put on someone, I think. How each person relates to their god(s) is and must be an issue between them and the aformentioned god(s) – anyway, I think it is very condemning to say that aregligious people have a particular tendency ignore questions of life, death and morality. I know some INTENSELY moralistic atheists – they just do not justify their morality with Word of God as much as with Word of Science.
And I know of religious people who have not spend one minute discussing those questions with their child, because the truth, to them, is obvious and unquestionable and preordained by God, thus no discussion, just accept and believe, the end.
I advise you to be a little careful. I think you’re putting a lot of labels on a lot of people, and assigning those labels some rather generalizing values that it is hard to back up with any significant evidence beyond your own personal prejudice (prejudice is not meant pejoratively here – EVERYBODY ultimately judges based on prejudice).
I was raised in a home of no significant religion. A bit of Christian awareness, because our country has a thousand years of christian history behind it, but that was it. And I think it’s pretty bold of you to suggest that as a result of that, my grasp of life and death and morality is somehow weaker than someone raised in a religious home. In fact, I believe I can make a case that because I was not raised with a religious explanation readily at hand to apply to my conundrums, I have spent considerably longer time considering the questions than someone who has a pre-fabricated answer to apply to whatever situation arises.
But I’m generalizing in retaliation here, and that might not be quite constructive.
When you are a parent, you are THE primary source of all ideas and values. Not only what you do, but what you DON’T do is going play a role in a child drawing conclusions about your values and convictions
And that was my point. That is exactly why as a parent you needn’t force-feed your child your values and plant upon them the label of “truth”. If you believe, for instance, gay marriage is wrong – to call back to a previous point – then the child is going to pick up on that and either adopt or reject that value, depending on whether they’re teenagers yet.
Same thing goes for values like “murder bad, charity good” and “socialism is awesome, capitalism sucks” – children are perceptive.
That is why I believe that it is far more constructive to ultimately teach tolerance by passing on the value that whatever you believe, you cannot expect others to believe likewise (because not everybody will), nor force them to (because belief happens on the condition of free will) – a value I hope that we can all agree on 😉
Now let me tell you, I have met people who fit your description of superficially religious, no-nonsense atheists who dismiss religion as “outdated make-believe bullcrap” without having spent the time or effort to actually understand what religion is or says. Those people are intolerant idiots, just the same as fundamentalists who dismiss anyone of the wrong religion as being misguided fools who will end up in hell or suffer the eternal absence of God (it used to be the same thing) or whatever.
Leastwise, that is my opinion.
This stability and opportunity to explore the many questions of existence is particularly meaningful to children who are still trying to make sense of the world.
This is probably true. What is also true is that religion is not the only thing that can serve this function. My father’s primary conviction is that everything is going to be all right. He never said it, but the way he goes about life makes it obvious that this is so.
And that’s all I ever needed, and I have met people of religion considerably less emotionally and philosophically stable than myself – so religion is certainly not a fool-proof security-blanket on that front.
And, ultimately, I think perhaps it is worth remembering that before all else. Before religion, before morality and before material values, what children need and what is the very basis for all welfare in the world, is love.
If a child is loved, it’s pretty much all going to be all right.
But that might just be my father talking.