Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
See Jonathan, I was raised by a mother who shares your philosophy, and I wish I hadn’t had her mushy I-don’t-believe-in-raising-children-with-religion-philosophy forced on ME! I would have liked the community, ritual, and connection to a higher power, but I was denied that.
Similarly, my husband was raised in a religious Catholic home, and while he has since rejected Catholicism, he felt the role of religion in his childhood was an extraordinarily positive one and a source of great strength and security. The fact that he rejected Catholicism as a religion doesn’t change his feelings. (Although he does say he got burnt out on being dragged to church activities too much, his criticisms are based on being over-scheduled and not about being raised with religion.)
I was making an argument that parent’s shouldn’t actively impose a religion or philosophical conviction on their children.
That, in and of itself, is a philosophical conviction. When you are a parent, you are THE primary source of all ideas and values. Not only what you do, but what you DON’T do is going play a role in a child drawing conclusions about your values and convictions – early on the ONLY values and convictions they know. Thus, they are imposed, whether it’s deliberate or not.
“Force” is a strong word. I am raising my children in a religiously observant home and I expect them to participate as children, with no expectation that they will or will not practice as adults. I am mindful of their saturation point, and try to limit their involvement in religious activities to that which is joyful and/or meaningful. Religion – in my case Judaism – creates a powerful starting point at which to discuss the “big questions” that most areligious or superficially religious parents either ignore or dismiss.
Again, we are dealing with children here – not adults. For example, if tomorrow Nana dies and my child asks “What do we do now?” Judaism has an answer. These are our rituals. This is what we expect from friends and family. This is how we grieve, and this is how long it is acceptable to curl up into a fetal position and mourn. This is how we heal, and this is how we begin to move on with the rest of our lives. In the absence of religion, such a situation becomes much messier. If that’s how you choose to run your home, so be it, but how can it be ethically wrong to want to give to a child a system of acting and believing that has been a source of stability and guidance to humans for for thousands of years?
Of course death is an extreme example. For me, religion also creates consistent guidance on how to welcome a baby, how to put aside sacred time for family and friends every week, holidays in which to atone for my wrongdoing, celebrate freedom, commemorate the world’s creation, mourn for mankind’s suffering. These are profoundly powerful experiences, and while I suppose many or all of them could be duplicated by my own creation, if I did so, it would no longer be a shared experience with a larger community. Whether Judaism is “right” about how it answers the question of how to deal with death or not to me is not as relevant as the fact that it is a lodestone to guide us through life’s difficulties and milestones. This stability and opportunity to explore the many questions of existence is particularly meaningful to children who are still trying to make sense of the world.
I sometimes think a lot of people were perhaps raised with authoritative and superficial religious observance, and then unfortunately conclude that therefore all organized religion as dogma that would be wasted on their own kids. At the same time, even the most anti-religious parents generally talk to their children about right and wrong behavior to some extent, expect them to sit down at the Thanksgiving table or around the secular Christmas tree, expect them to respectfully attend funerals and weddings and, hopefully, particulate in some kind of community service. If you do all this stuff well enough, you’re basically raising your children with religion (just not one of the existing ones!)