Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
Well, perhaps I’m shaping this too much as an assault on the moral integrity of the parents. Which it’s not supposed to be.
Let me rephrase my position: there are a number of choices that a child is unable to make, what with not having the ability to speak, remember long-term or survive at all without constant care and attention. Young children are physically very limited, and so it falls to the parents or whatever responsible guardians are at hand to make certain choices for the child. What to eat, what to wear, etcetera. Physical choices, that the child might remain alive and healthy.
The choices that parents cannot make are mental and spiritual choices. A parent cannot decide, for instance, which foods the child will like or dislike (much as many parents would love to be able to), or which teddy-bear it will most prefer to sleep with at night.
Just the same, the parent cannot decide which religion the child will belong to – the choice is not theirs to make.
And circumcision – whatever the practical benefits of the procedure – is still a religious induction.
So let me phrase it this way… A parent can have their child circumcised if it is physically or practically beneficial, certainly. But they cannot have the child circumcised as a Jew without also performing a complete subversion of the child’s freedom of choice.
Same thing with baptism. If there is somehow a beneficial effect to having water splashed in your face in a church, well, go right ahead. But you cannot baptize the child as a Christian without revoking their freedom of spiritual choice.
Perhaps that’s a better explanation of what I mean. As I’ve said, my point isn’t that circumcision does not have benefits – you’ve stated eloquently that it does.
My point is that to ritually induct someone into a religion when they’ve no say in the matter is to deny them their free will.
That’s really pretty much it.
My opinion following from that, which I would never hold to be absolutely morally imperative truth, is that it should not be done because in matters of religion, free will is absolutely essential. It’s pretty much the basis of the United States of America, as I understand it – freedom to worship however you want, or not at all.
Freedom of will is also pretty much the basis for the legal systems in… all of the world, really? I don’t think I know of any countries where it’s presumed that people do NOT act freely. It’s the basis of all trust, and therefore also of all love. Saturday-morning cartoons have explored this thoroughly: true friends and lovers love you because they freely want to and for no other reason.
Soo… yeah. That’s why my opinion. Free will must be free in all matters, or else there is no love and we will all die broken dejected and alone.
(PS: Not really, but I do love my exaggerations)