Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
mtgordon >>
In the case of amputation, I’d argue that if someone is, y’know, psychotic, then they’re not practising their freedom choice, they’re reacting to their psychosis. Just the same, I wouldn’t argue that a doctor should give heroin to an addict because they “don’t feel right” after having gone without it for four weeks.
It’s the same sort of mental imbalance, where the mind is not free, but in the throes of some chemical chaos.
And anyway, I was speaking theoretically, also because I agree that a reputable doctor willing to perform that sort of surgery without a VERY good medical reason is an uncommon creature at best.
On the circumcision: my argument against circumcision of young children applies equally to baptism. I’d also call it quite wrong to baptize a small child that has no voice in the matter, although in Christianity there is the “follow up” of confirmation, where the question is posed to people at an age where they might have some chance of informed choice. Although that chance is slim, at best. At 13 or 14 years of age, your religious and cosmological commitment is rarely your deepest concern.
In Denmark, most young people get confirmed as Christians mostly because we’ve a tradition of throwing big parties and bringing expensive gifts. Which is sort of depressing, really.
Teenagers making a commitment to God in order to have an extra birthday that year. And then once they’ve bagged the prizes, off they go with nary a glance in heavenly direction to (usually) drink heavily and spend extravagantly.
But that’s sort of besides my point, which is that baptism is the same sort of thing as circumcision, to me, except you walk away from baptism with a bit of water on your forehead rather than a sore… *hrum*, anyway.
I can understand the reasoning behind circumcision in the case of Jewish/Gentile children, and I can follow the logic. I just can’t accept the conclusion, that it should provide greater freedom to make a choice for someone early, so that they do not have to face that choice themselves later.
Again, my point is principal, not practical. I do not contest that the healing comes faster and with much fewer risks for a baby boy than for a grown adult.
The end result remains that you make a choice for the child that, yes, you are a part of the Jewish religion now, and when you get older then, if you want, you can choose differently.
And I think there’s a very fundamental difference between choosing pears or apples and choosing religion – unless of course you’re one of the kind of atheists who believes that all religion is ultimately the same nonsense with different flavours 😛
Anyway, that choice is fundamentally different in the sense that it is fairly neccesary for a child to eat, and just as it is quite conducive to their survival that they wear clothes in cold weather, even if the choice of which clothes is then left to the parent. Those are choices that it is your responsibility as a parent to make, because otherwise, well… the child dies.
Religion… not so much, I think.
But then, of course, I’m not of a religious mindset. And I suppose I’d be fairly hard-pressed to counter the argument that baptism/circumcision is neccessary to enter the pact with God that protects a child from the malicious influence of the Devil because, y’know, those things are completely impossible to verify.
If you make the presumption that the Devil is real and he is out to get your children (as some faithful people do), then religion suddenly becomes a very vital choice that you must make for your child.
Anyway, my point – or perhaps rather: my opinion – remains unchanged: regardless of all the beneficial practical reasons you can name that a child should be circumcised, it is still an unnecessary subversion of free choice to do so without expressed, informed consent.