Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65429
mtgordon
Participant

skyen:

If girls really wanted to have their clitorises removed (I can’t image why anyone would, but, y’know, theoretically), then that’d be fine, too, so long as they were of sufficient age to make the decision themselves.

I’ve heard accounts of people who want healthy limbs amputated, just because they feel wrong. Most physicians are regarding it as a psychiatric condition and are refusing to perform elective limb amputation.

You do not induct someone into a religion without as express and as informed consent as possible, and circumcision – as I understand it – is very much an inductive ritual.

So’s baptism. An important characteristic of both is that, barring laws against heresy, one is free to change religion in adulthood, and circumcision is no barrier, though lack of it arguably is. I don’t know of any religion that refuses to accept circumcised men as converts. That being the case, children are entirely able to reconsider the religious choices their parents made for them in their childhood. It seems to be common practice for sons of mixed Jewish/Gentile marriages to be circumcised in infancy in order that they may more freely choose which (if any) religion to follow in adulthood.

I’ve made lots of choices for my son. For one meal: pureed pears. For another meal: pureed apples. He didn’t have a choice when he was very small, and I don’t see a moral problem with my making that choice on his behalf when he’s very young. If he expresses a strong preference for one or another as he gets older, I’ll probably be OK with that, though I expect him to grow out of the pureed versions at some point. I’ll concede that circumcision is a bigger choice than pears vs. apples, but my point is that it’s naive to suggest that parents can never make choices for their minor children.