Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
With monogamy, there’s less transmission of sexually transmitted disease. Independent of children and the capacity to produce them, that’s a public health argument that favors marriage. Empirically, it’s more of an issue with gay men than with lesbians.
I realize I said I was done with this particular discussion, but I just wanted to say that is a good point and one I admit I have never considered. I wonder if more gays would practice monogamy if marriage were an option? I have heard people say (but haven’t confirmed) that while a substantial number of lesbians seek marriage, only a smaller minority of gay couples do. (And my personal anecdotal experience would follow that. I have known many “married” lesbians, but only one “married” gay couple. (“married” in this context to mean, those who consider themselves married, had a ceremony, and consider themselves spouses regardless of legal recognition.)
Back to circumcision…
…it can just as well become an inhibitive thing for anyone who doesn’t wish to belong to the Jewish religion (like, say, an atheist).
I realize this is a unfamiliar notion for many gentiles, but there are plenty of Jewish atheists. The president of my former synagogue was one. Albert Einstein considered himself a Jew even though (I think) he only believed in a Spinoza’s God. Of course there are many Jews who choose to not to claim their Jewish identity, but a Jewish identity is something more complex than religious belief. Judiasm is at the same time a religion, a system of ethics and tradition, a culture, and a peoplehood. Circumcision can play a large role in the identity of many Jewish men who embrace their Jewish identity for any or all of those reasons.