Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
Well, moving on, and hoping I’ve not forgotten too many points…
The argument that there’s a lower likelyhood of STDs in heterosexual marriage is still not a powerful enough argument, I think, that it should be reserved exclusively for men and women. Because that has absolutely nothing to do with the issue, which is one of human rights and not of practical problems.
It’s similar, in a way, to that whole torture-debate that’s been going on about waterboarding and whatnot – yes, you can certainly make the argument that the torture revealed critical information that saved countless lives, but the argument is completely irrelevant because torture is still illegal (illegal with very little consequence besides a sternly worded statement from the UN, I’ll grant, but still…)
Like you could argue that a guy only held up a liquor-store for cash so that he could feed his family, and that still wouldn’t change the fact that he has to do jail-time for committing the crime.
Anyway, my point is, regardless of whether it is better or worse for children to live with heterosexual or homosexual parents, and regardless of whether there’s more or less STDs and regardless of what a great upheaval for society it would be to have married gay people holding hands in the streets rather that unmarried gay people holding hands in the streets, the fact still remains – in my view – that homosexuals are still human and to deny them equal rights with the rest of society is no different than denying people rights because they’re black, female or not wearing the right kind of pants.
Now, if marriage carried no legal advantages, and didn’t entitle people to a whole host of additional benefits that are unavailable for unmarried couples, OR if civil unions carried every single one of the same benefits of marriage, no exceptions, I’d probably not care half a huckabee if gay people could have church-ceremonies or not. That’s just not the case, unfortunately.
And, well, even if we got around the problem of legal and social benefits, I think I’d probably still make an argument that a religion that promotes peace, tolerance, love and compassion as its primary virtues is committing a BIT of hypocrisy by being choosy about who they want to share their supposedly universal peace, tolerance and etcetera with.
… Okay, it’s getting very late. I should do well to get quiet before I get stupid. A good night to you all, whatever your opinions 🙂
A good argument is one that you don’t have to crawl out of a hole to walk away from 😉