Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65425
skyen
Participant

mtgordon – Great, I love a good argument 🙂

Seriously, if that Monty Python sketch were true, I’d be a regular customer. And I’d pay for the full half-hour up front and get it in writing.

Anyway, I made my point about circumcision in a slightly unclear manner, probably. I should stop writing things that need to be eloquent when it is late in the evening and I am not, as it were, eloquent.
I don’t really have a problem with circumcision, as much as I have a problem with the fact that the children don’t get to have say in the manner. It’s not so much about the procedure as it is that the procedure is made without consent.

If girls really wanted to have their clitorises removed (I can’t image why anyone would, but, y’know, theoretically), then that’d be fine, too, so long as they were of sufficient age to make the decision themselves. Same thing with piercings, tatoos, memberships of bookclubs, etc.

Because you are quite right! Culturally there’s good reason to circumcise, just the same as there are good practical reasons to circumcise people in the desert. So yes, I was wrong about the “no good reason”, part. What I should’ve said is I believe that the good reasons for circumcising male children young (faster healing, no memory of pain) is outweighed by the reason against: that they should have the choice themselves.

While certainly, if you are born jewish and grow up to remain jewish in faith, early circumcision is a major advantage culturally and practically. Only you cannot define from birth what a person is going to grow up to become.

I may have inflated the universal importance of my argument, though, because it’s really mostly a point of principle for me. You do not induct someone into a religion without as express and as informed consent as possible, and circumcision – as I understand it – is very much an inductive ritual. I’m sort of Immanuel Kanti-ish on some points, there are some things that on principle just don’t sit with me. Regardless of the practical and pragmatic arguments you could make for the practise, to me, the principle is still wrong.

But yeah. I should probably make clear that I do not have a universally valid argument for my point except that I would call it a subversion of free will on a point where free will is essential: religion. As has been said, circumcision and the ritual of the thing can be a good way for people to maintain their religious identity as Jews, and I believe that that, then, must work both ways: it can just as well become an inhibitive thing for anyone who doesn’t wish to belong to the Jewish religion (like, say, an atheist).
Sort of like being branded with a cross at birth, just to grossly overexaggerate.

Another thing I might do well to mention, that I not be misunderstood, is that your arguments, mtgordon, are (in my view) perfectly valid arguments for why circumcision is acceptable. I was trying to make the point that “because it’s ancient tradition” is not a valid argument for why circumcision is acceptable.

In my opinion, that is. I tend to forget to mention that everything I write is opinion and of no more gravity than that. I tend to presume that everyone else knows that it is, because I read everything everybody else writes as opinion.