Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
I suspect that the evidence supporting two parents will outweigh the evidence supporting four parents.
Honestly, when I have heard pluralists (the stable, fully-adult, consenting kind – not the weirdos in the compounds) make their argument and defend their lifestyle, the only logical critique I can come up with are not dissimilar from my critique of same sex parents.
Most of your arguments are not so much against gay couples being allowed to marry (the proposed change) but against gay couples raising children (arguably the status quo). That makes it hard to see the huge social change.
Correct. And if the institution of marriage could be entirely divorced (no pun intended) from family-building, I don’t think I’d have any objections. However, I believe marriage and family-building are inseparable topics. Yes, I know many people marry and choose to remain childless, but it is not these marriages for which the institution exists. Remember, a marriage comes at a cost to the government. Why is the government paying this price if not to encourage a level of stability for future generations? It’s not because it makes them feel good that two people are in love and have committed to each other.
This is why I think Colleen’s solution of “civil unions for everbody!” is probably the most sensible one given the current state of things. Everyone gets the same thing, but since the meaning of “civil union” is not as entrenched in our existing infrastructure, we would be forced to re-examine issues relating to parenthood on a case-by-case basis. (Whereas if gays are “married”, everything that comes with that would presumably be grandfathered in.)
I’m going to end there because I think I’ve said pretty much everything I have to say on the matter. I’d like to thank everyone for remaining civil for the most part. 🙂
I WAS planning to come here today and take on the circumcision debate, but Gordon said almost everything I have to say, right down to the comment about ear-piercing. Full disclosure: I am a Jew, and while I have no sons, I don’t think most gentiles fully appreciate the importance of circumcision in Jewish culture. The Reform movement (the largest and a quite liberal Jewish movement.) has removed MANY traditional elements from Jewish practice through the years, and once tried to add circumcision to the list for many of the reasons mentioned in this thread. The resistance to this was so vehement, the attempt to remove this practice was dropped. I daresay a boy being raised with any kind of significant Jewish identity – even a largely secular identity – is more likely to resent his parents for NOT circumcising than he is likely to resent them FOR circumcising.
Of course, there are also a number of reasons to believe that circumcision DOES have some benefit, including but not limited to a slight decrease in the spread of certain STDs in both men and women.