Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65403
mtgordon
Participant

skyen wrote:

Also, yes I would ask the Jews to stop circumcising male children.

Now you and I get to argue. 😉

I think it’s a crime to perform that kind of non-essential surgery on people who have no chance or ability to voice their consent or dissent.

I’m grateful that I had that surgery when I was too young to remember it and when I was young enough that the healing was fairly trivial.

And also, to exempt ancient Jewish tradition from criticism on the grounds that it is ancient Jewish tradition would be hypocritical in the extreme for a Dane. We had a case about a year back about some… I think they were somali parents who had their girls circumcized.

Apples and oranges. I’m certainly willing to argue that there are anatomical and physiological differences between men and women, especially in this context. “Female circumcision” (clitoridectomy) is primarily intended to dampen female sexual response and eliminate the female libido in an effort to reduce the risk of infidelity. It’s akin to castration except that it doesn’t actually affect fertility. Male circumcision is mostly hygienic in its purpose, and there’s ample evidence that infant male circumcision doesn’t significantly dampen libido, sexual response, or reproductive capacity.

surgery for no good reason on people who are unable to say “no”.

There are several reasons, independent of tradition. First, I don’t think it’s entirely coincidence that the tradition of male circumcision is most widely practiced in cultures with origins in arid climates. The combination of ubiquitous sand and scarce water arguably makes male circumcision a good idea, and the attendant problems don’t start at puberty. The alternative is likely to be much more painful over the course of a lifetime, or even a childhood. Granted, my son doesn’t live in a desert, and even in deserts, washing is easier than it once was. The other argument, popular in Africa today, is that circumcised men are significantly less likely to contract HIV, all other things being equal. Now, maybe there will be a reliable vaccine for HIV before my son is old enough to need it, and granted, my son doesn’t live in Africa. This may not be enough to convince you that male circumcision is universally a good thing, but it’s clearly not intended to be truly destructive, and there are circumstances in which it is clinically indicated. Put another way: it’s fairly trivial for a gentile parent to find a gentile surgeon to circumcise a baby boy, even in the absence of an ancient tradition, whereas I think it would be difficult for parents to find licensed physicians outside certain immigrant communities who would be willing to perform a clitoridectomy on a baby girl, since they would cite their Hippocratic oath to “do no harm.” Now, the argument in favor of circumcising infants rests on two bases. First, the procedure is simpler and is less likely to involve complications when it’s done on an infant. Second, infants will bear no memory of the procedure, whereas anyone old enough to make the decision is clearly old enough to remember the procedure. If it’s going to be done, it’s best to spare them the memory of the pain.

But once you have condemned traditional surgery on young girls, you cannot in the same breath defend the very same kind of surgery on young boys.

I don’t think traditional surgery is necessarily harmful. I’m not going to condemn ear piercing, for example, though I don’t much see the point in young children. The real question is whether the surgery is, in net terms, harmful. I believe that clitoridectomy is harmful and destructive, whereas I believe that male circumcision is harmless and possibly beneficial, and given the real differences between the two procedures, I see no inconsistency in holding these seemingly disparate opinions.

And we haven’t even gotten to my son’s other surgery…