Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65371
skyen
Participant

Also, yes I would ask the Jews to stop circumcising male children. I think it’s a crime to perform that kind of non-essential surgery on people who have no chance or ability to voice their consent or dissent.
And also, to exempt ancient Jewish tradition from criticism on the grounds that it is ancient Jewish tradition would be hypocritical in the extreme for a Dane. We had a case about a year back about some… I think they were somali parents who had their girls circumcized. They had the clitoris removed in order to prevent sexual stimulation, because that, according to their particular brand of…- I think it was Islam, would be a sin against God.
Needless to say there was a MASSIVE outcry against this practise, and thanks to our right-wing-supported coalition-government, special laws were made in record-time to outlaw the practise.

And it is SUCH a hipocrisy to me that no-one thought to apply those same laws to the Jewish people. It is the same goddamn thing: surgery for no good reason on people who are unable to say “no”. The girls were just unfortunate that they didn’t have foreskin, so they found something more sensitive to cut off.
The tradition for surgery on the female genitals was ancient as well – it had been practised long before Islam entered into it. Islam just did what religions to well and assimilated a local practise to ease the conversion of the misguided. All religions do this.
But once you have condemned traditional surgery on young girls, you cannot in the same breath defend the very same kind of surgery on young boys. That is hipocrisy and legal injustice.

So yes. I would ask a Jewish man to NOT circumcise his son, and age-old tradition be damned. If the son wants circumcision, he can make the decision on his own when he is of age. Everything else is an unjustified tyranny of tradition. “We have always done this!” does not mean there is nothing wrong with doing it.