Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65370
skyen
Participant

To respond to the young comedian-link JoAnn posted, I don’t really see that anything he said contradicted my point.

America was founded on the freedom to worship or not worship whatever someone wants to worship, and that being the principle, the line of consequences I set up still stands. State-sponsored discrimination through religious communities towards specific groups that are otherwise protected by national law is STILL an abomination to all legal justice.

More than that, even if America was originally founded on the idea of keeping the state out of the chuch and not the other way around, things – happily – change, and the primary failing of any conservative argument is that it is based on the idea that because something has worked for a long time it is by definition the best method.

A piece of comedy I feel expresses this quite eloquently:

I Drew This, March 8 2004

You can argue – and rightfully – that traditional marriage has BEEN the best way of doing things for a long time. You used to be able to make the argument that marriage as a sort of social adhesive to construct productive family-groups rather than expensive single mothers and problematic, roaming single men was adequate justification for protecting the institution of heterosexual marriage.

You cannot, however, say that the social method that was effective in the 40s is still effective today, because the world has changed. It is MUCH more possible for a woman today to be a single mother than it was fourty or sixty years ago. The institution of marriage or even civil union is no longer an important safeguard for women and their children, because a woman can support herself and her children (to an extent. Octo-mom might’ve been in trouble if she hadn’t gotten famous)

It might be more difficult in America, because you don’t have the same degree of rampant socialism that we do over here in Europe, but it is, nonetheless, possible, and Oprah will devote hours of primetime TV celebrating the strength and courage of those women who choose to raise their children single-handedly.

Gay marriage, as the comic-strip suggests, is really not an issue any different than slavery or women’s suffrage. It used to be that you could run a stable society on slave-labour, but you can’t anymore. Humanists everywhere would revolt, and probably with violence. And considering the amount of guns that are at large in the American society, it’d be very BLOODY violence.

It used to be that a woman’s only useful place was in the home, taking care of the children, darning the socks and preparing food, because there was no other way to get those things done and you couldn’t very well NOT do them. Today we have kindergardens and public educational systems, we buy our food largely ready-made for cooking and consumption and socks are usually thrown out when they become perforated.
And women are very much needed elsewhere, on the market, offering a range of skills equal to the menfolk. Without women in business, the world would quite simply collapse.

So you got to have women’s suffrage, because it’s going to be mighty hard to convince women to work for society if they cannot also have a say in it.

Conservatism has its good points, of course, just as liberalism has its flaws, and communism has yet to produce a single state that lives up to its own principles. But the conservative argument is invalid. It’s simple logic. A machine that has always worked will not necessarily work always and forever in the future.
I am not making an argument against conservatism as a whole, I am making an argument against another argument that happens to be conservative.

But hey, as that young comedian pointed out, everything I say is wrong because I’m a biased liberal. Unlike him. He’s a completely objective conservative.
Well, actually, I’m worse than that. I’m a biased socialist. That’s right! I topple nations with my unyielding support for universal healthcare – I’m sorry, socialized medicine, is the term – for illegal immigrants and all their family-members in other countries.

On an unrelated note, I find it so amusing that political pundits use the term “socialist” as an insult in America.
… and yet somehow they can still call Denmark – which is positively communistic in comparison to the US – a “valuable and dependable ally” in the physical and moral war against terrorism. But that’s a hypocrisy for another time.

Anyway, my point was… yes, traditional marriage HAS been a good thing. And now we have come to the point where it stops being a good thing and starts being a fairly nasty, discriminatory thing. Which is the point where it needs to change or die, in my opinion.