Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65356
mtgordon
Participant

when homosexuality is normalized, the result has been the marginalization of women

I’ve seen a bit of that anecdotally, gay men who have absolutely no use for women, and the entire society degenerates to a locker room. I think it’s the exception, though, and there are plenty of gay men who respect, appreciate, and enjoy the company of women. You’re also leaving out lesbians, whose stereotypical marginalization of men arguably counterbalances the gay male marginalization of women. Really, it’s much more of a danger in a strongly patriarchal society.

sexualization of children

Yeah, I was slightly creeped out the last time I read Plato’s Symposium. I think there are enough strong taboos still in effect there, especially with respect to boys. Girls are increasingly sexualized in heterosexual culture, as you note. My gut feeling is that this is a side effect of the overt sexualization of women; girls are simply imitating the behavior they see in adults.

I was actually PRO gay marriage until I read some anthropological material about homosexuality in various cultures, and it was enough to maybe think it’s a social change that should be approached with caution.

I’m not convinced it’s such a major social change. The number of committed gay couples is relatively small, and the biggest change is that they’re more open than they once were. They can have kids by one method or another, but it’s still quite uncommon, even here in Massachusetts, and the number of married gay couples with children is still fairly small. There are or have been cultures where, for example, male homosexual behavior was nearly universal. That’s not what’s being proposed here. As I see it, the fundamental question is whether society should encourage same-sex couples to be monogamous if they’re so inclined. If so, then marriage should be an option.

When I speak of the differences between men and women, I’m speaking of something of more substance than pink clothing and pants.

Anatomy and physiology? Fine.

But in some ways, I think androgyny IS a problem. The differences between male and female psychology has been recorded in the annals of literature, poetry, comedy, music, and art – across all cultures. It’s negating the obvious to suggest these differences do not exist.

I think the differences exist in some people, and I think they’re largely absent in some people. As I see it, there’s effectively an androgynous gender role that rejects the stereotypical masculine and feminine extremes, and I don’t believe the mean is at all pathological. On the contrary, I see the extremes as pathological. While at a certain visceral level I am unable to understand why a man would be interested in wearing a dress and makeup, I’m similarly puzzled by the desire of women to wear dresses and makeup. At the opposite extreme, I have absolutely no interest in sports, and I can’t for the life of me understand the passionate interest that others have for it.

Right now, an agency can give preference to married couple over non-married couples.

My favorite example of what is currently described as adoption by a non-traditional family is from the book Anne of Green Gables, in which a girl is adopted by a brother and sister who live together. Granted, it was one man and one woman, but they weren’t married and couldn’t legally marry each other. In the book, the adoption was uncontroversial.

If we embrace marriage as a “right”, are we still able to have a frank and honest discussion about best meeting the needs of children

In practice, it’s not about which of myriad choices is best for kids; it’s about which of two choices is better for kids. The reality is that most couples can have children without needing any third party’s permission, and in most cases, it’s arguably better to have them in the context of marriage than otherwise. That being the case, marriage traditionally doesn’t include any tests for fitness to raise children; it’s simply assumed to be better than the alternative, which is children conceived and born out of wedlock. Do straight couples have to pass any sort of test before having kids the old-fashioned way? Nope. It’s considered the right of straight couples to marry and have kids. It’s not a question of whether the family that conceives them is perfect; the only question is whether the children are better off without that family than with it. If parents are demonstrably unable to meet the needs of their children, then the government might declare them unfit and take away their kids. In practice, such accusations come up most often in custody battles, and they’re suggesting that only one parent is unfit.

an Enigma

I think she’d figured out that much already.