Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
Seriously, gays and lesbians have been reproducing the old-fashioned way since time immemorial. The big difference now is that they’re less likely to be closeted, and same-sex partners are more likely to be present.
Reproducing? Yes. Raising children in a household build on the foundation of two same-gender parents? No. Rare exceptions aside, this is what’s new.
I still maintain, too new to access. No matter how much you might LIKE to say it will make no difference (or for that matter that it will) there’s not enough data to draw a conclusion. (And incidentally, there IS some limited cases of historical record to show that when homosexuality is normalized, the result has been the marginalization of women and the sexualization of children. I was actually PRO gay marriage until I read some anthropological material about homosexuality in various cultures, and it was enough to maybe think it’s a social change that should be approached with caution.
Now, what I have read may be correlated but not causative, and the societies I read about were all ancient and/or isolated/primitive, and such an effect might not be duplicated in our society. But we don’t know. I know we’re already seeing more sexualization of children, but I attribute this to a general lifting of limits on sexual ethics across the board.
Is it a problem if men and women are androgynous? Women wearing pants, men cooking and sewing? Or is it necessary for successful child-rearing for men to be jocks and women to be pink, frilly, delicate flowers, just because that’s the way it’s always been in the past?
When I speak of the differences between men and women, I’m speaking of something of more substance than pink clothing and pants. We can have this discussion in greater depth if you’d like, but it’s kind of a different topic. (Not sure if it counts as “politics”), But in some ways, I think androgyny IS a problem. The differences between male and female psychology has been recorded in the annals of literature, poetry, comedy, music, and art – across all cultures. It’s negating the obvious to suggest these differences do not exist.
…but it’s illegal to discriminate based on sexual orientation, yes?
You’re not discriminating based on sexual orientation. As mtgordon accurately pointed out, homosexuals have been getting married forever. They just weren’t married to the gender they were attracted to. The legal institution has nothing to do with your level of sexual attraction.
I’m all about the civil unions. Legal civil unions for everybody! Religious/social marriage for the people that want it.
\
Honestly, I think this is the best solution, and the way I’d like to see the whole situation resolved.
Since gay couples can generally adopt children. (Wouldn’t it be better if those gay parents could marry each other?!)
Yes, it is. This is the best argument for gay marriage, in my opinion. Marriage functions to keep you legally bound even when, in the madness of raising children, the best of people at least momentarily contemplate just dumping everything and running for the hills. While I don’t think having two mothers or two fathers is the ideal, any parent who is able to walk away without consequence is worse, overall, for children.
However if gays marry, then is there any recourse by which adoption agencies can give preference to opposite sex couples? Right now, an agency can give preference to married couple over non-married couples. (Or an artificial insemination clinic or surrogacy agency, for that matter.) I’ve always felt that same-sex couples and singles should be legally permitted to adopt, but I’ve also always felt that it is reasonable – all else being equal – for an agency to give preference to a traditional family when possible. Will agencies be legally able to do so if gay marriage is legal? I don’t know.. I believe I recall reading something about Catholic adoption agencies pulling out of Massachusetts for this very reason. (Don’t hold me to that).
If we embrace marriage as a “right”, are we still able to have a frank and honest discussion about best meeting the needs of children, or are we going to get so hung up on the “sameness” of both kinds of marriage that we can’t discuss the possibility that a child is better off (again, when possible and all else being equal) of having both a mother and a father in their lives?
Now that’s just unsportsmanlike. 🙂
I don’t know… it’s fun to remain an Enigma… if you know what I mean. 🙂