Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65340
skyen
Participant

In my outsider’s view, the problem seems to be one of seperation of the church and state – more specifically the lack of it.

I think it’s been pointed out that marriage is not – as it perhaps ought to be – just a religious institution. It carries economical and social traits and advantages provided by the state and many, many important private services (like healthcare). And as a result, denying any demographic access to this institution is, ultimately, government-sponsored discrimination, no different from denying women the right to vote, or forcing black people to give up their seat on the bus for white people. It’s less extensive, certainly, but fundamentally of the same nature.

It really becomes quite a conflict of signals and values – the government grants tax-exemption and economical support to religious communities and organizations that discriminate against gays, while at the same time it claims to recognize and champion the natural right of all human beings to the pursuit of happiness in whatever form it might take.

To my eyes, the logical consequence of a free democratic society with a properly segregated church and state is that there should be no discrimination on the part of the government for any reason against any members of society on the grounds of race, gender, political conviction or sexual preference and etc.
Meaning that the government cannot support any organization – religious or otherwise – that advocates discrimination.
I.e. the government cannot grant tax-excemption or other such benefits to any religious community that refuses – for instance – gay marriage. Or transsexual marriage, or marriage between people with no genders.

But then we run into a seperate problem: if the government ceases to provide benefits to religious communities that do not accept gay marriage, but continues to provide them for the communities that DO, all of a sudden the government is conducting RELIGIOUS discrimination, favouring those religions whose views please the government best. And that is the first step on the road to a bad place.

And then you’re trapped between a rock and a hard place, where the only real way out seems to be the cessation of ALL benefits and ALL support for ALL religious communities. Which still poses a problem for religious freedom, because it means that smaller religions that cannot muster sufficient finance to support places of prayer and religious education in their chosen direction are suddenly at a major disadvantage against larger religions, only that – at least – is a problem with capitalism as a whole and not with the government.

Or else – since we’re getting so theoretical – if all religious communities chose to accept gay marriage, rather than embark on a path that will eventually lead to a complete end to governmental support for religion… Well, if they did accept gay marriage (and transsexual and genderless, etc.), that whole string of problems would never have to happen in the first place.

But I’m just dreaming here.

Also, yeah, I’m sorry. This is really my mode of discussion – it’s rather stream-of-consciousness-ish.

So yeah, in summary, it seems to me the only way out the conundrum is a complete and utter seperation of church and state – with all the consequences that entails… or else the anti-gay Christians (and Muslims and Jews, etc.) stop being picky and start practising some indiscriminate compassion already.