Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
In a nutshell, in the case of interracial marriage, saying “you cannot marry X person because you are Y race”, would be invalid when it is illegal for the government to discriminate based on race, which it was at the time of this case.
No, it was struck down under the due process and equal protection clauses of the 14th amendment, which don’t mention race at all. Race is just the historical context for the 14th amendment; it’s not actually part of the language of the amendment.
Saying “you cannot marry X person because you are Y gender” is a different issue because it IS legal to discriminate based on gender in limited circumstances. The government can gender-segregate barracks, dorm rooms, bathrooms, etc, and it is legal – presumably any circumstance in which the physical differences between men and women are a factor.
Infants and toddlers are often changed in whichever bathroom is appropriate for the parent. Transsexuals and those for whom gender is clinically ambiguous are another gray area. Moreover, as I previously noted, the gender-segregation of dorms and the like ignores homosexuality. There are a lot of assumptions being made here, and they’re not universally correct.
Marriage, as an institution, was created, and has existed for thousands of years, as a result of the physical realities of men and women. As much as we like to think of it purely in terms of love and intimacy, that is a relatively recent poetic perspective. As a legal institution, it has nothing to do with that.
Marriage has many rationales, and intimacy is among the most significant. At a very basic level, marriage is a framework in which sex is broadly considered permissible. As a legal institution, it historically has centered on protecting women and children from love-her-and-leave-her men. You want to sleep with my daughter? OK, but there are strings attached. This rationale is arguably less relevant in the context of same-sex relationships. However, I disagree with the argument some have made that marriage is solely about children and that a marriage between two people who would not be able to have children is unnatural. There are plenty of cases of older adults marrying without any real prospect of offspring, and it’s generally uncontroversial.
A major social change takes a couple generations to accurately assess.
Like Loving? Seriously, gays and lesbians have been reproducing the old-fashioned way since time immemorial. The big difference now is that they’re less likely to be closeted, and same-sex partners are more likely to be present.
Naturally if you believe men and women are identical than this issue is irrelevant to you, but if you DO think men and women are different
Is it a problem if men and women are androgynous? Women wearing pants, men cooking and sewing? Or is it necessary for successful child-rearing for men to be jocks and women to be pink, frilly, delicate flowers, just because that’s the way it’s always been in the past?
the onus is on you to explain why the other forms of marriage are somehow “dangerous”
I went over this in brief earlier. Incest produces inbreeding, which is bad for the health of the offspring. The precise legal cutoff is a bit ambiguous; there are societies where first cousins often marry, and I suspect that some states allow such marriages. Child marriage involves dubious informed consent; without effective consent, marital intercourse is statutory rape. Polygamy is a bit more difficult. The strongest argument I’ve heard against polygyny (one man, many wives) is that it leads to a surplus of single men with no marital prospects, which is socially destabilizing. Other arguments involve earlier wives being neglected in favor of subsequent wives, but in fairness, serial monogamy has the same effect, arguably to a greater degree.