Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
There are certainly precedents for curtailing civil rights in the interest of society without those curtailments being unconstitutional (e.g., yelling “fire” in a crowded place).
True. But then the onus is on you to explain why the other forms of marriage are somehow “dangerous” but the concerns about homosexual marriage I mentioned above are irrelevant. In fact historically, there is a HUGE precedent for polygamy, adolescent marriage, and incestuous marriage. It’s not all about some weird fringe Mormons in a Utah compound – there are reasonable, sane, people in loving, committed relationships who make a case for their marriage that I think is no less valid than than the case for homosexual marriage. And if you don’t buy into the concerns about motherless or fatherless home, but still feel that single parenthood is not ideal – then if two is better than one, why isn’t three better than two?
And I’m not just being snarky and asinine here claiming that it’s all going to lead to people marrying their cats. I really do think these are valid arguments that should be taken seriously. Incidentally there is already a grassroots effort beginning by pluralists to get their marriages recognized. (I think they call themselves “polysexual” or something.) And I’ve had occasion to hear their case, honestly, it sounds as reasonable and understandable as the homosexual marriage position to me (and I actually *am* emotionally sympathetic to the gay marriage cause, but I just still maintain there are valid concerns.)
Really, I think the whole conversation is primarily an exercise in debate. I think gay marriage being legalized/normalized is inevitable, because the vast majority of opposition do an embarrassingly piss-poor job of making a coherent case, and proponents for it appeal to emotion (including mine) regardless of whether they make a coherent case or not. Win for gay marriage. It’ll just take time and we’ll have to see what happens.
Oh and Colleen!! I think I know who you are! 🙂 Now that I’ve voiced my controversial views however, maybe I should remain anonymous. 😉