Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65332
serendipity
Participant

Why is same-sex marriage bad for society?

There’s insufficient data to say for sure. Again, just like no one can know that it’s good (or neutral) for society, we can’t know that it’s bad, either. If we’re honest, we all have to admit we’re just taking our best guess. It’s 100% a new idea – even in societies where historically homosexuality was normalized and accepted, homosexual relationships were distinct from marriage. Marriage was strictly the domain of procreation and childbearing, and homosexual relationships were venues for intimacy, companionship, and pleasure.

There is however some REAL data to suggest that children who grow up without a mother, or without a father, DO suffer consequences as a result. Unusual circumstances aside, children raised by gay couples will exist in one of these categories. Do such motherless and fatherless children spontaneously implode? Turn into pumpkins after midnight? Inevitably go insane? I think it’s safe to say “no”, and most children, whether raised by a single parent or two men and two women, or three adults or seven, if the parent(s) are stable and parent responsibly, will turn out to be decent people. But that doesn’t mean there won’t be any issues that, while such issues are minor on an individual level, can potentially have a larger impact if it is a social norm. More homosexual marriages means a larger number of children grow up without relating to a male or female in their home. Naturally if you believe men and women are identical than this issue is irrelevant to you, but if you DO think men and women are different, if you believe studies that suggest that motherlessness and fatherlessness carries negative consequences, it’s not something you want to see become supported and encouraged by your society.

The ironic thing is, 50 years ago, this would have mattered less as the biological nature of a homosexual couple would be self-limiting. However with ever-expanding field of fertility medicine, there’s nothing to stop female homosexual couples from having children, and I’m sure more and more options will open up for males as well. (Which is a whole other matter… I have concerns about the over-use of fertility treatments that I think has already begun to open a Pandora’s box of issues for everyone, heterosexuals included.)

But in addition to more homosexual couples having children, the more no-fault divorce and homosexual marriage is normalized, the more people (particularly women) will inherit that lifestyle with existing children. I’m not someone who thinks homosexuality is strictly a choice, but I do buy into the Kinsey scale theory for a large percentage of people. Ironically, even though I think it’s gay men who are more demonized, on a societal level, I’m more concerned about society becoming overly feminized, and fathers getting increasingly removed from child-rearing (the continuation of an already widespread trend.) For physical reasons, lesbians are more likely than gays to have children, and for psychological reasons, females are more likely than males to have custody of children and turn another woman for intimacy later in life. Anecdotally I’ve already witnessed this happen twice just among women I know, and I do not live where gay marriage is legal. Women I like and respect and I think are good moms, that I think, through a combination of no-fault divorce and an increased social acceptance of homosexuality, felt comfortable leaving their men and domestically engineering with another woman, unconsciously crowding out the men from their lives (just as men have been unconsciously filtered out of many aspects of the social strata where women have become more dominant. Another issue!)