Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65331
serendipity
Participant

mtgordon – Ugh, I had written a huge response to you and then my computer tanked. In a nutshell, in the case of interracial marriage, saying “you cannot marry X person because you are Y race”, would be invalid when it is illegal for the government to discriminate based on race, which it was at the time of this case. Saying “you cannot marry X person because you are Y gender” is a different issue because it IS legal to discriminate based on gender in limited circumstances. The government can gender-segregate barracks, dorm rooms, bathrooms, etc, and it is legal – presumably any circumstance in which the physical differences between men and women are a factor. Marriage, as an institution, was created, and has existed for thousands of years, as a result of the physical realities of men and women. As much as we like to think of it purely in terms of love and intimacy, that is a relatively recent poetic perspective. As a legal institution, it has nothing to do with that.

Regarding marriage, it appears as if gay marriages have no deliterious effects on society. Children seem to do fine in them, and they are apparently no better or worse than straight marriages.

This may be true, but we do not have enough data to make an assessment either way. A major social change takes a couple generations to accurately assess. Gay marriage has been legal in a small part of the country for a short period of time, and only a minority of gay couples currently raise children, and fewer still have we seen how they turn out. “Seem to do fine” and “apparently” isn’t substantial enough to make a final determination. Looking at anecdotal evidence, children raised by single parents also “seem to do fine”, but I don’t think enough evidence to conclude that it is irrelevant whether one has one or two parents.

This would bring me to Colleen’s question:

Why is same-sex marriage bad for society?

Next post: Apparently I’m too verbose for the JoCo forums!