Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65324
Colleenky
Participant

serendipity said:

Colleenky said: “Guess what, folks. When the will of the people violates the state constitution, then their will is null and void.”

So Colleenky, I do recall you saying in a previous post that it is reasonable for there to be restrictions on marriage. If denying marriage to someone who wishes to marry the same gender is “unconstitutional”.. isn’t it also “unconstitutional” to deny marriage to someone who wishes to marry multiple people or a cousin or a fourteen-year-old in accordance with their cultural and/or religious traditions? And this is not a far-fetched notion – there are already pluralists who are beginning to make the same case that *their* marriages should be legally recognized as well.

Ah. The inevitable “slippery slope” argument. Let’s assume, for argument’s sake, that marriage is a fundamental civil right. There are certainly precedents for curtailing civil rights in the interest of society without those curtailments being unconstitutional (e.g., yelling “fire” in a crowded place). Those decisions are made on a case by case basis, and public policy is a valid criterion for consideration. Not to dismiss your questions, but they’re tangential to the issue at hand. The question is, why should we prevent two consenting adults from marrying based solely on their sexual orientation? Why is same-sex marriage bad for society?