Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65320
mtgordon
Participant

JoAnn: I’m simply not convinced this all this fuss is about the religious principles of florists or bakers. In the presence of a functioning free market, I doubt that people are going to bother suing florists or bakers. And is it really a sin to sell flowers or cake to sinners? Really, what sort of test does one have to pass to buy flowers or cake from such people? I can understand how people might be opposed to assisting in abortions if they believe that abortion is a sin, but I don’t think that same standard applies to selling flowers or cake.

As for housing, there are plenty of same-sex roommates happily renting property from social conservative landlords. When I was in the dorms in college, single rooms were in short supply, and mixed-sex living arrangements weren’t allowed. Instead, we had room after room: two guys, two guys, two guys. If two of the guys were on, shall we say, unusually friendly terms, the university, like any other landlord, could look the other way. Same-sex roommates in rental housing is strikingly common, and it’s most often done for the sake of reduced expenses. As you note, since current law doesn’t allow discrimination in housing on the basis of marital status; a man and a woman can apply for an apartment, and a landlord can’t refuse to rent to them simply because they aren’t married. That being the case, landlords who insist on renting only to those who adhere to their religious principles are already running afoul of the law, and it’s far more often an issue with unmarried straight couples. Landlords who wish to avoid renting to gay couples can look into rental properties that would appeal more strongly to heterosexual couples. Sell the one-bedroom units near gay bars, and buy some multi-bedroom units near good schools, playgrounds, etc. Put a swing set in the back yard. Get rid of the lead paint. Granted, there are gay couples with kids, but they’re not terribly common, and they tend to have smaller families.

I’ll raise another conscience-based argument where I come down opposed to what are perceived as religious liberties. Somali-immigrant Muslim taxi drivers at MSP (the Minneapolis – St. Paul airport) were refusing to pick up passengers carrying alcohol or dogs, including service animals, on the basis of a perceived conflict with their religious principles. Given the shortage of non-Muslim taxi drivers at that airport, such passengers often had few alternatives. Taxi licenses at the airport were granted by a regulatory authority that decided, once the problem had gone on long enough, that they would suspend the licenses of drivers who refused fares. I support that decision. If you’re not willing to pick up fares, you should probably consider a different line of work.

serendipity: Check my link to Loving. The decision stated that marriage is a civil right, but it tried to paint its application of the 14th amendment in a narrow, racially-based context so as not to broaden the scope of the argument beyond interracial marriage. It’s currently described in case law as a civil right, but it’s one that’s effectively limited in scope. I fully expect that once enough states have legalized same-sex marriage, the Supreme Court will revisit that argument.