Reply To: Political Statements
Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements
If it could be proven that marrying a fourteen-year-old or multiple people would result in stable, healthy, bonded units that would support a stable, healthy society, then I would agree that there’s no reason to disallow those practices.
But wait – I thought were were talking about civil rights here! If it’s a civil right it doesn’t matter if it’s stable. It is my civil right to express ideas freely, even if those ideas are unstable and unhealthy. It is my civil right to practice whatever religion I choose, even if it is an unstable/kooky/unhealthy religion – even if the social influence of my religion is negative (but not directly encroaching on the rights of others). It is my right to a fair and speedy trial, protection against unreasonable search and seizure, etc, even though if I didn’t have those rights, there would likely be fewer criminals on the streets. Part of the American ideal is the idea that we sacrifice some stability and security for liberty. Civil rights are above such judgments. Civil rights are about personal liberty – not about what is best for society.
The moment you start saying “wait, I don’t think our society would benefit from plural marriages, or adolescents marrying” you are admitting that marriage isn’t a civil right. That it an institution that exists for a societal purpose, and that it is reasonable to place restrictions on it.
And that’s fine. You can still believe that and say “I think plural marriages are not stable and healthy for society, but homosexual marriages are.” That’s a perfectly fair position. But that is the distinction between believing that homosexual marriage should be legal, and believing that it is a civil right. Those are two different issues, though for whatever reason, I rarely see people identify the difference. (Actually, I know exactly the reason, and it is understandable. People feel very passionate about homosexuals being permitted to marry, and the perception is that identifying it as a civil rights issue will more quickly enable this, without really thinking about what consequences might occur if that same logic is extended beyond applying extending to homosexuals.)
By the way Spiff, are you the same Spiff that makes those spiffworld WOW videos? I LOVE them and watch them all the time! 🙂 (New to the forums here!)