Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65312
serendipity
Participant

I am in the "it goes against the will of the people" folks, but I my positions have absolutely nothing to do with religion.

Colleenky said: "Guess what, folks. When the will of the people violates the state constitution, then their will is null and void."

So Colleenky, I do recall you saying in a previous post that it is reasonable for there to be restrictions on marriage. If denying marriage to someone who wishes to marry the same gender is "unconstitutional".. isn't it also "unconstitutional" to deny marriage to someone who wishes to marry multiple people or a cousin or a fourteen-year-old in accordance with their cultural and/or religious traditions? And this is not a far-fetched notion – there are already pluralists who are beginning to make the same case that *their* marriages should be legally recognized as well.

And their logic is 100% valid under the notion that marriage is a civil right. If it's a civil right, then why should someone's second spouse be relegated to second-rate status just because the law does not recognize their marriage as valid?

I maintain that marriage not a civil right, but rather is a costly legal contract between married persons and the state. Our society has decided to endorse because it serves the society's interest. Thus, said society can rightfully impose or change whatever restrictions on said contract they feel is in the society's best interest. The interracial marriage comparisson is erroneous in 2009, because in 2009, we all agree (with the exception of kooks) that people of different races are fundamentally the same, yet differentiating between genders is acceptable (girls' schools and boys' schools, gender-specific restrooms – not to mention the gender differences involved with procreation, and procreation is more or less the whole reason the institution of marriage exists in the first place.)

On the civil rights issues, homosexual people should be free to live as they choose, and any archaic laws involving the prohibition of homosexual acts or cohabitation should be unilaterally stricken from the books. Laws that dictate how you can live and act, outside of what is necessary for public security and safety, are what violate the concept of civil rights. There is no "civil right" however, that guarantees you access to government-granted perks, which is what marriage fundamentally is.

If a society chooses to, through due legislative process (say, a state proposition or legislation introduced by elected representatives), modify the restrictions placed on the legal contract of marriage, that is valid. But to say it is a constitutional issue is not only in my estimation incorrect, but logically throws out any future context for maintaining any other restrictions on marriages.