Reply To: Political Statements

Home › Forums › Everything Else › Political Statements › Reply To: Political Statements

#65311
Colleenky
Participant

My friend Jim, whom I’ve mentioned in this thread before, makes a great argument that making same-sex marriages illegal actually violates *his* church’s freedom of religion, since his church sanctions such marriages. (There are plenty of Christian churches that do.)

In CA at least, the opposition argument no longer has anything to do with religious freedom. First, they argue that overturning Prop 22 (which would have made same-sex marriage illegal) was overturning “the will of the people” by “activist judges.” Guess what, folks. When the will of the people violates the state constitution, then their will is null and void. This is why we then got Prop 8, which actually amended the state constitution. Second, they argue that children *might* be taught about same-sex marriage in school, because there is a provision in the CA state education code which says that schools shall teach about marriage. Here is the relevant code section, referenced on the opposition’s website:

51890. (a) For the purposes of this chapter, “comprehensive health
education programs” are defined as all educational programs offered
in kindergarten and grades 1 to 12, inclusive, in the public school
system, including in-class and out-of-class activities designed to
ensure that:
(1) Pupils will receive instruction to aid them in making
decisions in matters of personal, family, and community health, to
include the following subjects….
(D) Family health and child development, including the legal and
financial aspects and responsibilities of marriage and parenthood.

First of all, this code is vague, and the leap to “OMG! Teachers will start advocating gay marriage!” is tenuous at best, absurd at worst. Also, parents have every right to make their feelings known to their child’s teacher and excuse their child from the lessons. Oh, and, y’know, talk with their kids themselves about it. Yes, religious people, there is information in the world which conflicts with your belief system, and your children will probably hear it at some point.

Again, I assert that opposition to same-sex marriage is based on fear and has no supportable basis in public policy.

ETA: CA has domestic partnerships for gay couples, which does not exactly grant all of the same rights as marriage. And even so, a domestically partnered couple still has to jump through a bunch of extra hoops in regards to health insurance and things. They can’t simply present a marriage certificate like het couples can. And CA has an added bit of craziness. Domestic partners MUST cohabitate before registering! How bizarre.