I say ICE, for it's complexity, great lyrics, and the fact that it didn't bother me for the first few listens, but has much more longevity than Re: Your brains once you get into it.
Sign Up for the Jonathan Coulton Mailing List!
We'll send you four free tracks to start,
we'll never give your address to others,
and we'll make sure you know about the latest
news and upcoming concerts.