Reply To: Favorite Song Tourney Matchup #32 Re: Your Brains vs. Shop Vac

Home › Forums › Forum Games › Favorite Song Tourney Matchup #32 Re: Your Brains vs. Shop Vac › Reply To: Favorite Song Tourney Matchup #32 Re: Your Brains vs. Shop Vac

#63549
three08
Participant

neither is an especially original concept – suburban angst versus zombies in a mall? RYB wins in originality because it at least has one interesting twist, ie the history between bob & tom, but shop vac wins out when it comes to emotional depth and, i would assert, the complexity and quality of the music. they both have audience participation aspects when it comes to the live show, although i wouldn’t want or attempt to claim that shop vac can rival RYB in that respect.

on balance, i favor the masterful rendition of a common cultural notion over the solid and enjoyable rendition of a common cultural notion with an interesting twist. (shop vac 4 lyfe, yo.)