Reply To: Blue Sunny Day, New Song!
Home › Forums › JoCo Music › Blue Sunny Day, New Song! › Reply To: Blue Sunny Day, New Song!
@voidptr: Not sure about “off”, but it’s slightly different from what I would have expected, inasmuch as it’s consistently one inversion lower. First chord is D major first inversion, whereas the more natural/obvious choice for me would have been second inversion. It’s partly an issue of tone quality, partly of how it sits with the vocal range. In Mike Lombardo’s SF3 entry “Caroline” he does something similar, also in D, but he goes for the higher inversion – it’s somehow a bit more punchy, even ignoring the vocal and the slightly more complex harmonies. But I think you’re right about lack of dynamics. Assuming the part was either written straight to piano-roll, or quantised and edited there after being played in, it’s probably a case of the note lengths and velocities being too similar in each chord tone and between chords, whereas a human player would have accented and lengthened individual notes (“Caroline” gets an agogic accent on off-beats), even if he/she were striving for a “mechanical” sound.
From the first hearing of BSD, I couldn’t help but compare it to “Caroline”, if for no other reason that they are both bouncy tunes in D with a driving quarter-note rhythm that came on my radar in a similar time frame. With the benefit of hearing the complete arrangement, I still think the live guitar part is fantastic, since it really is a summary or reduction of everything else.
(Hindsight time: when I originally said that I hear banjo, it was entering on the four-note pattern after “yellow gold” to join guitar. In reality it turns out to be guitar joining piano.)