Reply To: Favorite Song Tourney Matchup #29 The Future Soon vs. I Crush Everything
Home › Forums › Forum Games › Favorite Song Tourney Matchup #29 The Future Soon vs. I Crush Everything › Reply To: Favorite Song Tourney Matchup #29 The Future Soon vs. I Crush Everything
Well, for these songs, it would really depend on what the next project was. I think ICE is more suitable for a wide range of topics and audiences, but The Future Soon might not be chosen if the project didn’t have an at least somewhat geeky target audience, or if it was something that really wasn’t meant to be funny. (I know both songs have their serious, applicable-to-anyone sides, and I know that audiences usually laugh at ‘I hate my beak’, but The Future Soon has many more laugh points and many more geek points and so would be less suitable for a lot of more serious or wide audience stuff.) And yet, there are certain movies that The Future Soon would be perfect for. So perhaps if I recognised the director (I wouldn’t) and knew what kinds of movies different directors make (I don’t) and it happened to be somebody who made movies about awkward, somewhat geeky teenagers, or romantic comedies, or robo-apocalypse movies, I’d choose The Future Soon. But in most cases, especially with someone writing a new adaption of The Little Mermaid, I think I’d be safer with ICE. Okay, it still sounds quirky at first, and it’s less obvious what’s going on on the first listen, but in the context of a movie or something like that, it’d be clear what it’s really about.
TFS is really straightforward, telling a story from the beginning, giving all necessary information, while ICE is kind of more abstract, you wouldn’t necessarily guess that it’s a giant squid, and maybe you don’t need to, but you’d probably be confused if you didn’t know. So actually, this makes TFS a better song to play to a friend as an introduction to JoCo, but the fact that it’s such a concrete story (even if only in a daydream) means that it’s only going to be useful to a fairly narrow range of art projects. So for the big-shot I’d play ICE.
This doesn’t help me decide which to vote for, though.