Reply To: When You Go (Piano Cover)

Home › Forums › JoCo Projects › When You Go (Piano Cover) › Reply To: When You Go (Piano Cover)

#62688
BorbaSpinotti
Participant

Great work as usual. I really admire the fact that you start all your JoCo work with careful analysis of what he did; even if you were to do something completely different one day, I’m sure it would be informed by deep knowledge of the original. Oh, and you should really cross-post this in the “JoCo Looks Back creations” thread.

You bring up an interesting issue with the angle on the impact of the accompaniment. When reduced to just a vocal line, songs seem to get more timeless, stripped of obvious association with contemporary cultural surroundings. It is this very fact that allows standards to become standards – if we were only allowed to listen to original versions, they would eventually tend to sound quaint and otherworldy (case in point: I was quite shocked the first time I heard Ethel Merman recordings of Cole Porter songs that had since become standards!) JoCo did make a conscious decision to cast the song in nostalgic colors though, so it was never intended to sound particularly modern. I guess what you did was to strip down the paint layers and expose the beauty of the wood underneath. End of metaphor mixing…

The above issue is quite poignant for me, because I have played around with treating the song as a standard (i.e. a bare melody+harmony to hang one’s own interpretation on) and somewhat invevitably, it turned into a jazz waltz. In a way, this went exactly opposite to what you did, and especially after some recent forum posts from people who say how much they love the song, I’m sure there are some that would consider it sacrilegeous, so I guess I’ll keep it as a thought experiment only.