Reply To: A Comic For Mr.Coulton

Home › Forums › JoCo Projects › A Comic For Mr.Coulton › Reply To: A Comic For Mr.Coulton

#51304
jinx
Participant

I remember you, pyromanic — from the Geekdom thread, right? You and Colleen were talking about invader Zim?

I like a lot about your comic, but I think the phrase on the banner is just too jarring. I don’t think it’s what a real girl would put on a banner if she had a crush, and I don’t think a friend of hers would hesitate one instant about refusing to help hold it.

You might find it worked better if you made the banner some lyrics quote or reference that was a little sappy — or even a banner shaped like a creature, where the guy character had to hold up, like, the monkey’s tail or the squid’s tentacles or something. He’d be associated with the sappy quote, but not looking quite so much like he was pulled into saying it himself.

Also, I think you’d benefit from trying out some different facial expression signs. The girl’s mouth in the third panel was hard to figure out — was she talking? Was she grimacing?

That’s my constructive criticism — welcome back, though!