Reply To: Masters of Song-Fu
Home › Forums › JoCo Music › Masters of Song-Fu › Reply To: Masters of Song-Fu
Paraphrased from my blog comment: “I love both JoCo’s and P&S’s song, and I can’t help but giggle uncontrollably at work when I hear Big Dick Farts a Polka (through my earphones). While I love Jonathan’s style, there’s something to be said for P&S’s in-your-face ‘instant gratification’ that he so effectively channelled. So if I were to vote right now it’d definitely be for the P&S-style song. But I’m going to mull it over, let Live sink in a bit more, and then decide. ”
I definitely liked Live much more about the third time I listened to it. But there are a few rhymes that poke at the back of my head, and even though they’re minor, I would probably notice them even if I weren’t in full criticism mode. It half-sounds to me like maybe this was intentional, but to me these somewhat detract from the song: day/graves, find/mine, mob/god. The last one probably wasn’t intended to rhyme but I think it would have sounded way better if they had written that section so that it did.
I listened over JoCo’s song and I can’t find any such criticisms.
So I think I’ll be voting for JoCo. But like I said, I really enjoyed both songs and I think both artists did an excellent job of mimicking each other.