Reply To: Song Book

Home › Forums › JoCo Tabs › Song Book › Reply To: Song Book

#38006
BorbaSpinotti
Participant

"Fake book" means different things to different people I guess. To me, it's the kind of book that a soloist or combo can use on stage to do a plausible performance with, without the hassle of overly much detail and page turns, or of course the logistics of producing it in the first place. The kind of fake books I love tend to have:
– Reasonably big notes and chord symbols
– Intros and endings, when the song is supposed to reflect a canonical recorded version
– Line breaks that correspond with phrases where reasonable (typically 4 bars per line)
– Important breaks, counter-melodies and rhythmic hits noted
– A binding that doesn't break or close itself – think plastic spiral-bound rocks!

It is pretty much a lowest-common-denominator of notated (pop) songs, although it is still bloody easy to do badly.

On the other hand, collections of "piano-vocal" standard published sheet music are also often labelled fake books, confusing the issue somewhat. Unfortunately, doing this for JoCo songs can get hairy, since we would then have to agree on what is the "standard" piano-vocal arrangement, and I can see that being a headache. With only one contributor per song (and no reviewing), it can be done, but it doesn't lend itself to collaborative work, and the quality of each song would reflect more on the arranger than on the source material.

So if Colleen and I are good children, we'll just churn out a bit of material, hoping somebody else joins in, and the bigger debates can go on in parallel.