Reply To: Song Book
One of the nice things about the lead sheet format is that it teaches you how to sing the song. Look at Bry’s comment in another thread for a good example. The staff can be used to notate lots of song information as well; Key signatures, time signatures, dynamics, etc. If used correctly it can also save on space with repeat signs, volta brackets and other repetition symbols.
However most of this information can be picked up by listening to the song and that’s almost always going to be an option.
Ultimately I think it comes down to the fact that we’re geeks. The more information at our disposal the better. I think most of the people who end up picking up the book will fall into that category as well.
Maybe we’ll end up needing two books. One a lead sheet set and another “pocket” book.
As it is right now it looks like we’re going with the lead sheet/fake book format. I really don’t think there is a need to get more complex except maybe for posterity.